Alexei Ramirez – CHI (76.7 Runs Created, 32.1 Runs Saved = 108.8 Total Runs Production)
After an odd year where his bat fell and he couldn’t hit any doubles, Ramirez had a stunning 2010 season. He slugged .431 thanks to 18 homers and 29 doubles, his batting average was a more than acceptable .282, and he scored 83 runs. His glove work was spectacular, really – a ball magnet who also helped on the double play. He earned the new contract…
Cliff Pennington – OAK (66.6 Runs Created, 26.9 Runs Saved = 93.5 Total Runs Production)
Would you have believed he was the second best shortstop in the AL? His bat is marginally better than average, he played a lot of games, and his defensive range is stunning. His replacing Marco Scutaro was one of many reasons the As moved up in the standings last year.
Elvis Andrus – TEX (63.8 Runs Created, 26.0 Runs Saved = 89.8 Total Runs Production)
Has NO power, but slaps a few singles, draws some walks, and can scoot a little around the bases. Oh – and he’s probably the best glove in the AL. Robbed of the gold glove again, but will start winning it probably this year. The voters are weird about these things…
Alex Gonzalez – TOR/ATL (77.3 Runs Created, -0.4 Runs Saved = 76.9 Total Runs Production)
The wind was blowing out, huh? Had a great first half, which allowed Toronto to trade him while his stock was up to Atlanta for Escobar. I always liked him when he was a Marlin – did a lot of good things. Still can play enough, but isn’t a long term solution for anyone anymore and he can’t seem to stay somewhere longer than a year…
Yunel Escobar – ATL/TOR (53.5 Runs Created, 18.3 Runs Saved = 71.8 Total Runs Production)
Struggled mightily last year with Atlanta, came to Toronto and started to show signs of life. I think he’ll rebound in 2011 and is going to be worth a late round draft pick in your fantasy leagues.
Jhonny Peralta – CLE/DET (69.7 Runs Created, 2.1 Runs Saved = 71.8 Total Runs Production)
Moved to third base in Cleveland, then brought to Detroit in hopes that he could solve the shortstop problem and keep Detroit in contention down the stretch. He’s really not a very good defensive shortstop (he was a pretty good third baseman, though), but there are plenty of guys who are worse than him still getting chances to play. And Peralta can put a few runs on the board, too.
Yuniesky Betancourt – KC (65.3 Runs Created, 5.3 Runs Created = 70.6 Total Runs Production)
He actually had a pretty good season on the surface… Some power, he cut down the strikeouts, and fielded his position pretty well. I can’t tell if anyone thinks he’s a championship type player, but he isn’t hurting you either.
Reid Brignac – TB (40.3 Runs Created, 14.3 Runs Saved = 54.6 Total Runs Production)
Hits like Ben Zobrist and played well enough in the field to allow Jason Bartlett to hit the road in 2011. The Rays will be just fine.
Derek Jeter – NYY (80.0 Runs Created, -27.4 Runs Saved = 52.6 Total Runs Production)
Was the top shortstop last year because his offense made up for his total lack of defensive range. He got a lot of at bats at the top of the Yankee order but was a league average hitter – which knocked him well down the ladder in 2010. He can bounce back a little offensively, but he may not have a position with this team – except as captain. The Yankees were in a tough position in dealing with Jeter, who really is a superstar as a personality, but no longer as a player. Realistically, he only has a couple of years left unless he bounces back a lot in 2011.
Erick Aybar – LAA (62.0 Runs Created, -9.7 Runs Created = 52.3 Total Runs Production)
Not his best season – has little power, doesn’t get on base or slap a bunch of singles, and didn’t play his best shortstop last year. Can do better, and will have to if the Angels want to win the division again.
Ramon Santiago – DET (36.0 Runs Created, 11.6 Runs Saved = 47.6 Total Runs Production)
Four players got time here, including Adam Everett (some glove, no bat at all) and Danny Worth (not yet ready for the majors). Santiago was nearly effective in the role last year, but it was a fluke and he really isn’t the answer.
Jason Bartlett – TB (61.6 Runs Created, -16.4 Runs Saved = 45.2 Total Runs Production)
No longer the rangy shortstop of two or three years ago, still contributes with the bat even when his average slips to .250. Hits a few doubles, gets on base, and can still run smartly around the paths.
Marco Scutaro – BOS (79.9 Runs Created, -35.1 Runs Saved = 44.8 Total Runs Production)
That didn’t work out, did it… Scutaro wasn’t blessed with great range when he was younger, and after signing the big deal in Boston, he really fell off the map defensively. Offensively, he’s still pretty good, with a decent eye and a bit of power. But if you are looking for reasons that the Boston pitching struggled in 2010 it starts right here.
J.J. Hardy – MIN (44.3 Runs Created, 0.2 Runs Saved = 44.5 Total Runs Production)
Only played 101 games, but was reasonably productive when he played. Not appreciably different from Betancourt – just less playing time. Alexi Casilla is currently listed as the new starter – a slap hitter with some range, but to be honest – might be a step down from Hardy.
Josh Wilson – SEA (33.5 Runs Created, 8.9 Runs Created = 42.4 Total Runs Production)
Does a good Jack Wilson impersonation – a bit less offense and a bit less defense (a little less range, a bit more error prone), but also a bit younger. Not the answer without a serious upgrade in his output, which isn’t likely, and will have to be replaced if Seattle is going to compete.
Asdrubal Cabrera – CLE (45.6 Runs Created, -9.5 Runs Saved = 36.1 Total Runs Production)
Not a championship level player at this level – unlike his solid 2009. In fact, Jason Donald made more plays per nine (though he committed a few more errors), and is a bit stronger offensively. (I discuss Donald with the second basemen…) Cabrera had a tolerable batting average, but – again – if you aren’t going to contribute more than 60 runs with the bat, your glove has to be solid – and Cabrera’s has not consistently been above average.
Jack Wilson – SEA (19.4 Runs Created, 12.9 Runs Saved = 32.3 Total Runs Production)
His best days are behind him; he can’t hit as well, can’t stay healthy, but he still does play a mean shortstop.
Cesar Izturis – BAL (35.0 Runs Created, -9.1 Runs Saved = 25.9 Total Runs Production)
If you’re going to hit like Mark Belanger, you had better field like him, too. Izturis disappointed, putting up just 2.5 runs per 27 outs thanks to a .230 batting average and just 15 extra base hits in 150 games. Now a utility player, with J.J. Hardy moving in to play short.