Matt Kemp (LAD): The best centerfielder in baseball for 2009. Hit close to .300 in Dodger Stadium with power and some patience. As an outfielder, he’s graceful and fast – which also helps him steal bases. And, he’s just getting his career started. (120.9 Runs Created, 15.4 Runs Saved = 136.27 Total Run Production)
Mike Cameron (MIL): Now with Boston, Cameron had the same type season he’s had for a decade now. Hits for decent power, draws a few walks, doesn’t run as much as he used to – and still plays a mean centerfield. Time may be running out, but he’s been very, very good for a long time. (91.4 Runs Created, 12.7 Runs Saved = 104.12 Total Run Production)
Nyjer Morgan (WAS): I mentioned him with the left fielders because that’s where he played in Pittsburgh, but he was equally impressive defensively in Washington as a centerfielder. And, as a hitter, he was electrifying as a National. One hopes he returns and leads the team with about 110 runs scored. (76.2 Runs Created + 26.9 Runs Saved = 103.1 Total Run Production)
Michael Bourn (HOU): Got a lot of hits and a few walks helping to a .355 OBP. Steals a lot of bases (61) but for a burner isn’t the same defensively as Cameron. Still – a valuable commodity on a team that could use a few more players of his production. (98.0 Runs Created, 1.2 Runs Saved = 99.19 Total Run Production)
Nate McLouth (PIT/ATL): Even hitting 20 homers with a .350+ OBP, it seemed like an offseason for McClouth. Missed more than a month of games – so if he gets back to 150 games, he’ll move up two or three notches. (84.4 Runs Created, 0.6 Runs Saved = 85.0 Total Run Production)
Tony Gwynn (SD): The only centerfielder with 800 or more innings to make 3 plays per nine, JR doesn’t hit like his dad, but he moves like the younger version of his dad. In San Diego, that helps a lot. There’s some room to improve here, but without any power, he needs to get his OBP near .400 to be among the great ones. (57.0 Runs Created, 25.15 Runs Saved = 82.20 Total Run Production)
Kosuke Fukudome (CHC): Not really a centerfielder, as the Cubs found out. Gets on base, but really isn’t that good a hitter, and a mild disappointment to the Bleacher Bums. On the other hand, new centerfielder Marlon Byrd was less productive than Fukudome in 2009. (75.7 Runs Created, 1.88 Runs Saved = 77.56 Total Run Production)
Shane Victorino (PHI): Has become an offensive force with midrange power and speed, but looking at the defensive stats, maybe he should go back to right and let Jayson Werth try his hand at center. Either that, or he just needs to take charge more… (102.9 Runs Created, -25.6 Runs Saved = 77.31 Total Run Production)
I mentioned Marlon Byrd. The new Cubs centerfielder would rank here based on 2009 production…
Cody Ross (FLA): A fan favorite, but isn’t really fast enough to cover center – a heck of a right fielder, though… Has some power, swings at a lot of stuff – does it all with a smile that every mom would be proud of. (79.9 Runs Created, -6.5 Runs Saved = 73.39 Total Run Production)
Carlos Beltran (NYM): Still ranks highly despite missing 81 games because, well, he’s still an incredible talent. Was off to perhaps his best start ever before the knees gave out – .325 and maybe 20 homers with a killer OBP and 20 steals. If he’s healthy, he’s the top player at the position. A big IF, though… (68.5 Runs Created, 4.5 Runs Saved = 73.01 Total Run Production)
Andrew McCutchen (PIT): There’s a lot to love – and one wishes that Pittsburgh could have kept him, Jason Bay, and McClouth in the outfield just to see how many runs they could have produced. He’s got some learning to do in the outfield, but I liked what I saw in 2009. Power, Speed, Patience – the three cornerstones of a great player. (78.2 Runs Created, -13.9 Runs Saved = 64.32 Total Run Production)
Colby Rasmus (STL): The Cardinals think he’s the real deal and he’s certainly off to a great start. I don’t think he’s as fast as McCutchen and in a few years, the power will even out. As such, I think McCutchen will be the greater star. McCutchen had the better batting average, OBP and slugging numbers – but Rasmus looked a little more polished in the field. (62.5 Runs Created, 1.4 Runs Saved = 63.91 Total Run Production)
Aaron Rowand (SF): May have lost a step, and his offensive numbers (as expected) have slipped some since arriving in San Francisco from Philadelphia. No better than a run-of-the-mill outfielder these days. (66.2 Runs created, -3.5 Runs Saved = 62.67 Total Run Production)
Angel Pagan (NYM): Beltran’s usual replacement, hit .306 with some power and a little patience. Isn’t quite in Beltran’s league as a fielder, but the Mets certainly could have done worse. He could start for a few other teams. (63.5 Runs Created, -4.7 Runs Saved = 58.82 Total Run Production)
Gerardo Parra (ARI): Played a few hundred innings in center – not too badly. He’s the third rookie of this group (Fowler, below, would be fourth) and he might not be too bad either… (56.0 Runs Created, -2.5 Runs Saved = 53.49 Total Run Production)
Dexter Fowler (COL): Scrappy hitter, steals a few bases, but otherwise is about a league average offensive performer – not as much range as you would like. Fowler was nowhere near responsible for the return of Colorado to the playoffs. (62.0 Runs Created, -9.1 Runs Saved = 52.93 Total Run Production)
Rick Ankiel (STL): Now plying his trade in Kansas City, the oft-injured Ankiel’s story seems to be heading in the wrong direction, wouldn’t you think? Batting average fell, power has fallen since being tagged as a steroid user, and his OBP was .287. Fielded better than other years, but missed a lot of innings… Lord help the Royals. (43.7 Runs Created, 7.9 Runs Saved = 51.59 Total Run Production)
Carlos Gomez, the Twins centfielder who takes over for Mike Cameron in Milwaukee, would rank here.
Elijah Dukes (WAS): Got some time here – not horrible, but not really what the Nationals had in mind. Could still work out as a corner outfielder or fourth outfielder. (48.8 Runs Created, -1.4 Runs Saved = 47.47 Total Run Production)
Willy Taveras (CIN): What happened? Suddenly lost his batting stroke and finished at .240. Ouch. Will find a job as a fifth outfielder, pinch hitter, but probably will never be a regular again. Unless Kansas City calls. (36.0 Runs Created, 10.8 Runs Saved = 46.78 Total Run Production)
Chris Dickerson (CIN): Played the fourth outfielder role, but should be the starter in center for 2010. Gets on base, runs, covers ground in the outfield. Not quite a leadoff hitter, but not a problem there or in the two spot. (38.2 Runs Created, 7.8 Runs Saved = 45.98 Total Run Production)
Willie Harris (WAS): Can play all three outfield positions, gets on base even with a low batting average and has pop in the bat. Valuable bench guy for any team… (48.4 Runs Created, -4.3 Runs Saved = 44.11 Total Run Production)
Chris Young (ARI): This is what happens when a .240 hitter goes into an extended slump – his whole game suffers. Hits for power on those occasions he makes contact, but was a zero in every other way. (39.6 Runs Created, -8.0 Runs Saved = 43.02 Total Run Production)
Ryan Spilborghs (COL): If he played in center, instead of Fowler, they’d lose nothing defensively and if his bat returns, would get some more offense, too. I don’t PROMISE that, but I do believe that. (40.0 Runs Created, 0.0 Runs Saved = 40.01 Total Run Production)
Jordan Schafer (ATL): Injured after earning a spot in the lineup, spent too long trying to play through a wrist injury and killed his first shot at a regular position… Now has a fight to get his job back now that McLouth is in town. Can fly in the outfield – will get a job somewhere. (16.3 Runs Created, 7.7 Runs Saved = 24.03 Total Run Production)
Cameron Maybin (FLA): Another burner in the outfield – has some power but needs to make more contact. Will be the starter in Florida for 2010, but needs to hit in months that start with something other than S. (21.7 Runs Created, 2.2 Runs Saved = 23.95 Total Run Production)