Last week, I gave you the NL Gold Glove and Brick Glove winners and losers… It’s time to do the same for their brethren in the AL. As a reminder, here’s how I do it:
1) Look at the number of plays made per every 800 balls in play, because it provides a level playing field and because, in effect, one extra play made is essentially removing one point of batting average from each hitter.
2) Make modifications for things like flyballs and ground balls allowed by pitching staffs.
3) Make modifications to middle infielders based on double plays.
4) Remove infield assists from first basemen’s putout numbers.
5) Convert plays made/not made into runs saved/lost based on values for each hit as determined by Pete Palmer – with hits assigned by position.
6) Determine additional benefits for runs saved based on double plays and errors.
For the lists below, you’ll see two numbers for each player. Positive numbers are always better. The first number tells you how many plays he makes per 800 balls in play more or less than the average guy. Nelson Cruz made 14 plays every 800 balls in play more than the average right fielder. That’s a lot. Derek Jeter’s first number is about -9, which means he makes nine plays less than the average shortstop per 800 balls in play. The second number tells you how many runs that player saved his team (or cost his team, if the number is negative). So, the effect of Nelson Cruz making 14 extra catches for ever 800 balls in play (and not make errors, or contribute to double plays) was to save his team about 35 runs over the course of the season. Again, a negative number is bad – a player’s range or being error prone would cost his team that many runs.
14.0 34.5 Nelson Cruz (TEX)
11.9 17.0 Ryan Sweeney (OAK)
Cruz made a lot of plays – only Suzuki made more, but Ichiro played more than 250 additional innings and had just 24 more putouts. Like Jayson Werth, Cruz had more putouts than Texas center fielders – something that rarely happens. Sweeney was solid, but in only 600 innings. Shin-Soo Choo or Alex Rios were third by my reckoning… For years, Rios should have been in center and not Vernon Wells.
– 8.4 -28.7 Nick Markakis (BAL)
-10.4 -23.3 Michael Cuddyer (MIN)
-10.2 -17.8 Magglio Ordonez (DET)
Jack Cust just missed this list and he only played 400 atrociously lousy innings… Markakis gets raves for his arm, but if you don’t get to any flies, you aren’t helping the team. Ordonez is a regular to the brick glove list and should be a DH.
10.0 20.0 Carlos Gomez (MIN)
7.4 16.4 Adam Jones (BAL)
5.4 14.4 Franklin Gutierrez (SEA)
All the young legs. Milwaukee will appreciate how good Gomez is defensively (the pitchers will, anyway). I thought Gutierrez should have moved Sizemore to right in Cleveland and he proved me right.
-5.9 -16.8 Vernon Wells (TOR)
-5.9 -16.5 Jacoby Ellsbury (BOS)
-7.4 -14.9 Marlon Byrd (TEX)
Vernon Wells has been a slow centerfielder for years – it’s about time to move him to left or right field. (Just listing his range numbers, 2006: -3.7, 2007: -5.1, 2008: -6.2, costing between 10 and 17 runs to his team each year.) Ellsbury was lousy despite setting the record for most putouts in a game. And pity the Cubs if they put Byrd in CF…
5.3 17.8 Jason Bay (BOS)
4.6 15.3 David DeJesus (KC)
4.2 12.5 Carl Crawford (TB)
Bay sure does get a bad reputation for his defense, but he wasn’t a problem last year. I think Boston will miss him. Unlike the NL, the AL has a few guys who can really play here and are truly left fielders.
-14.2 -15.3 Adam Lind (TOR)
– 4.7 -12.3 Johnny Damon (NYY)
– 4.6 -10.2 Delmon Young (MIN)
Adam Lind is a DH who is forced into left. Damon is 36 and is starting to show the effects of old and injured wheels. And Delmon Young has NEVER been a good fielder.
14.1 30.8 Elvis Andrus (TEX)
7.6 15.7 Cesar Izturis (BAL)
3.5 11.1 Erick Aybar (LAA)
If anyone in their right mind really looks at this, there is NO WAY that Elvis Andrus should have been denied a gold glove. Okay – he makes a few too many errors. But he makes SO MANY plays. Compared to the worst fielding shortstop in the AL – the guy they gave the gold glove to – Elvis had 55 more putouts and 67 more assists in about 23 fewer innings. 122 additional plays.
-9.2 -14.2 Derek Jeter (NYY)
If you go by guys who played a lot of innings, Alexei Ramirez and Marco Scutaro (or Asdrubal Cabrera) would be second and third. However, I thought I would point out that even though Marco Scutaro is a step up from the 2009 position holders – he’s NOT going to make Boston’s defense airtight. Scutaro’s range is -5.0/-6.4. However, Julio Lugo’s 243 innings were brutal (-20.4 range, costing 12.3 runs) and Alex Gonzalez was a step up from abysmal to just bad (-10.9 range, costing them 5.6 runs). Jason Bartlett’s ankle injury was serious – he went from a gold glover to a problem.
9.3 31.9 Evan Longoria (TB)
14.0 28.6 Adrian Beltre (SEA)
8.6 21.7 Melvin Mora (BAL)
Chone Figgins is above average, but defensively is about twenty runs worse than having Beltre out there. I stand by what I wrote before – it’s not an improvement to have Figgins in Seattle, though the backups will play less. Longoria is the real deal.
-16.9 -39.0 Michael Young (TEX)
-17.0 -12.9 Ty Wigginton (BAL)
Michael Young must have been watching Elvis get all the grounders, too. This just proves that because you once were a decent enough (not great, though) shortstop you can’t just try playing third base and become good at it. It’s taken YEARS for Alex Rodriguez to go from a lousy third baseman to one who is just a little below average.
7.9 23.3 Placido Polanco (DET)
5.9 18.8 Aaron Hill (TOR)
6.1 16.4 Robinson Cano (NYY)
And Detroit didn’t want Polanco anymore? He remains very, very good at second base. Philadelphia hopes he can still play third but I have my doubts that he’ll be GREAT the way he is great here. Cano has improved every year. Ian Kinsler just missed this list – he’s regularly awesome.
-11.0 -31.2 Brian Roberts (BAL)
– 6.5 -19.9 Alberto Callaspo (KC)
That Mora and Izturis were solid makes me think that there could be a statistical bias here, but Roberts’ numbers, even with help, are still plain old bad. By the way – this isn’t news. He’s been below average three of the last four years.
2006: -4.8 -10.4
2007: 1.2 5.2
2008: -4.3 -12.6
2009: -11.0 -31.2
That’s a pretty big dip, which is part aging and probably part batters hitting in a different direction last year.
14.3 37.8 Kendry Morales (LAA)
12.1 24.4 Russell Branyan (SEA)
8.2 15.1 Chris Davis (TEX)
Mark Teixeira, for the first time in a while, just missed making this list. He’s usually in the middle. I had no idea Morales was that good (or, for that matter, anyone on this list), but I will be watching to see if he remains this good going forward.
-33.5 -28.0 Victor Martinez (CLE)
– 9.6 -20.5 Justin Morneau (MIN)
-14.3 -17.3 Hank Blalock (TEX)
If you count his time in Boston, Martinez cost his teams more than 35 runs – he’s a catcher and can’t really play the position. Morneau’s injury wasn’t just killing his bat – he was less and less mobile as the year went on.