Last Five Seasons:
2009: 87 – 75 (2nd, NL East)
2008: 84 – 77
2007: 71 – 91
2006: 78 – 84
2005: 83 – 79
Finally people started seeing the Marlins for what they are – a talented team despite the low payroll who, when healthy and getting a modicum of pitching, can hang with anybody.
Runs Scored: 772 (5th, NL)
Runs Allowed: 766 (11th, NL)
Like in 2008, the Marlins edged opponents on the scoreboard but came ahead on the deal in terms of wins and losses. The reason for this is because the bottom of their pitching is ATROCIOUS, and when they lose they tend to get pounded.
The Marlins won 11 of 12 to open the season because six games were against the Nationals when the Nationals really stunk up the joint. I remember sitting in the office talking about this with Jose Gomez – the Marlins were about to play the Pirates and we were talking about how they could be 14 – 1 and heading home.
Instead, they lost a lot – losing 24 of the next 32 games. This was because only Josh Johnson was winning any starts and Ricky Nolasco, who SHOULD be an ace, needed a trip to the minors to find himself.
When Nolasco returned, that gave the Marlins two decent arms the rest of the way. Then, Hanley Ramirez and Chris Coghlan started getting two hits every night (or so it seemed) and the Marlins climbed back into the race by the end of August and made a run at a wild card slot before running out of time.
All along, it seemed like the Marlins were just two players away from being as good as anybody in the NL. They needed one more starter and one more really good reliever. No – they don’t have ALL the firepower of the Phillies, but with a core of Ramirez, Cantu, Uggla, and Coghlan setting the table, that’s a lot of runs to work with. The helpers – Cody Ross, both catchers – Ronny Paulino and John Baker, Cameron Maybin, and bench hitters like Wes Helms and Ross Gload – all contribute.
Two more pitchers.
A completely healthy Josh Johnson pitched 209 impressive innings, winning 75% of his decisions and saving his team 33.7 runs. Ricky Nolasco, as mentioned earlier, found his mojo after a trip to the minors and finished the season by striking out 16 batters and nine in a row in his final start. If you look at his numbers, you’d never know he had a 5.06 ERA – winning record, solid K/BB numbers, and not hit TOO badly. He did give up hits in bunches, though, and that was his problem.
After that, Chris Volstad gave up 29 homers in 159 innings, pushing his ERA over 5.00. Sean West was tolerable but a little green in his 20 starts. Anibal Sanchez pitched half a season of okay ball – an ERA under 4, but watching him start is excrutiating because he always seems to be pitching his way out of trouble. Andrew Miller made 14 starts and got worse as the season progressed, eventually hitting the bullpen and then AAA. Rick VandenHurk made the Netherlands WBC team, and had eleven okay starts.
Looking forward, that’s the problem the Marlins face with the rotation. Nolasco will be better, but can Sanchez make 30 starts? Will West improve? The Marlins made a late acquisition, picking up Nate Robertson from Detroit – and he HAS to be better than Andrew Miller (also, formerly of Detroit). If Robertson can make 30 reasonably good starts, this is a step up. I like the potential of improvement here – but they still require a lot of bullpen help.
Let’s look at that bullpen. The Marlins tried Matt Lindstrom as a closer, but he got hurt during the WBC and his 100 MPH fastball seemed very flat and hittable. Leo Nunez, a decent 8th inning guy, became the closer and was okay because he doesn’t really have the control needed. They combined for 41 saves, but a lot of chewed nails.
The Marlins did find their usual surprise and cheap help in the middle relief corps… Kiko Calero allowed just 36 hits in 60 innings, but 13 were homers (must have all be solo shots), which led to a very surprising 1.95 ERA. Renyal (1972 Ford) Pinto is a wild lefty who had more good innings than bad ones. Florida even has a legitimate long reliever in Burke Badenhop – a guy who looks good the first time through the lineup but gets killed in the fourth and fifth innings – so he becomes a reliever who frequently makes multiple inning runs when the team needs it. Brian Sanches and Dan Meyer were solid most of the season. Even Brendan Donnelly came over and gave the team 25.1 good innings. So, there was a lot of depth in the pen – there just wasn’t a shut down closer and a lot of relievers always seemed like they were living on the edge.
Looking ahead, Calero is gone – in his place will be Clay Hensley. I’m not sure I get it – he has little control and couldn’t keep his ERA under 5.00 in the spacious confines of Petco Park in San Diego. The rest of the pitching staff returns with just those two additions (Hensley, Robertson) and two subtractions (Lindstrom and Calero). So, while the rotation should be 30 or 40 runs better, the bullpen could give half of that back.
John Baker and Ronny Paulino shared the job in 2009 and will do so again – at least until Brett Hayes is ready for a test drive. Both hit enough and are natural platoon partners; Paulino was tolerable against the run – but otherwise are rather bland catchers. Neither is known for handling the staff (and who would take credit for last year’s pitching) or avoiding mistakes.
Defensively, not very good. Offensively, as good as you might want.
Jorge Cantu was solid at first – but then looked out of practice playing third base when Nick Johnson arrived last year. Johnson has NO range as a first baseman – so he was allowed to play DH for the Yankees. Cantu will move to third base to give Gaby Sanchez a shot. Sanchez hits like Pete O’Brien in a good year, about .280 with mid range power. I just don’t know that Sanchez will be that much better defensively. He will be better than Johnson, though.
Dan Uggla rips homers, got on base despite a dip in his batting average, and started to look slow defensively. A late bloomer, Uggla makes more good plays than bad ones, but a slipping range means that he’s a candidate to be moved if the Marlins start to fall out of the race.
Hanley Ramirez is one of the two best players in the NL right now – the best hitting shortstop (heck, as good as anyone except, perhaps Pujols or Braun) in baseball and a tolerable fielder. He’s very deliberate as a fielder, as if trying not to make throwing mistakes, but he doesn’t have the acrobatic range of the really good ones. Hitting .340 with power, though, nobody seems to care. Except, perhaps, the pitching staff.
Last year, Emilio Bonifacio played a lot of third, but he’s really better suited as a bench player. Wes Helms is a solid bat off the bench and plays third and first well enough. Mike Lamb comes over to replace Ross Gload as a veteran lefty bat off the bench. Gload was impressive last year – so he’ll be a challenge to replace (and will be missed). Brian Barden also made the club, but I don’t know where he’ll play with this lineup. Perhaps he’ll be a late inning defensive replacement for any of these guys…
Looking forward, I see the defense slipping another ten runs but the offense holding steady.
Chris Coghlan is a hitter, an amazing collection of line drives – patient at the plate and has good enough speed to sneak 30 steals. He’s just not much of a left fielder. Eventually, he’ll have to move – but he’ll bat leadoff until he’s 40.
Cameron Maybin earned the starting nod last year, got off to a slow start with the bat, and needed a trip to AAA to get his swing back. He’ll get a second shot – and hopefully he’ll stick. I see him as the new Preston Wilson, and if he ever puts it together, that’ll be just fine.
Cody Ross is a shaved head bundle of energy and smiles – and can play a decent right field and back up Maybin in center. He has decent power but you wish his batting average was closer to .280 than .250. You need guys like Ross on the team… Fan friendly, contributes in many different ways, and compliments the stars on the field.
Brett Carroll and Emilio Bonifacio will provide bench support. Carroll is actually a pretty good fielder, but doesn’t appear to have MLB hitting skills.
I like this unit to be much better than last year – possibly 30 – 50 runs better offensively and 20 runs better defensively because (a) Maybin is an AMAZING fielder and will be here every day and (b) Coghlan will be more comfortable out there than last year.
The best hitters at AAA are already on the Marlins – Sanchez, Coghlan, and Maybin. And, there weren’t a lot of pitching prospects in New Orleans to write home about.
Sean West came out of AA Jacksonville, as did Chris Leroux. West may stick for a while, but Leroux will probably not be a future star. He has decent enough control, gets a few strikeouts, but at 25 is not really a young prospect. Jacksonville must be a tough place to hit. The top average was Bryan Petersen‘s .297, a 4th round pick in 2007 out of Cal-Irvine. Look for him to get a shot at AAA, and be a fourth outfielder before too long.
The big prospect at AA was Mike Stanton, whose batting average stunk, but has SERIOUS power and is only 20. He’ll be among the first guys to get a shot at right field if Cody Ross gets hurt. Logan Morrison is another first base prospect who has Mark Grace-like skills – good OBP and a little power.
A+ Jupiter featured Stanton (for a while) and another teen – Matt Dominguez who will be a future third baseman on this team by 2012. Looks like a young Mike Lowell right now, but it’s still early. Check him out in Jacksonville in 2010. All of the really good Hammerhead pitchers throw strikes, but few better than Elih Villanueva, who walked just 18 in 158 innings, striking out 110. He’ll be moved up to AA as well.
For two years, the Marlins played better than the ratio of runs scored to runs allowed would have suggested, and that’s a problem. It means they could be unlucky this year. On the other hand, there is room for improvement. The team should allow 40 fewer runs and possibly score 30 more. Marlins ownership EXPECTS a playoff team, and I see them on the fringe of that – 89 wins. My HUNCH is that they’ll be over .500, but closer to 84 wins – but the Marlins fan in me hopes my system is right.