Last Five Seasons:
2010: 95 – 67
2009: 103 – 59 (World Series Champs)
2008: 89 – 73
2007: 94 – 68
2006: 97 – 65
Runs Scored: 859 (Tops in the AL)
Runs Allowed: 693 (5th in the AL)
Based on this, the Yankees could have won the division with 98 wins…
Picked by many to repeat as AL East and World Series champs, the Yankees just missed by a game of winning the east, and had their starting rotation held up (or had they acquired Cliff Lee) they might have won the series, too.
The Yankees got off to a hot start, taking 15 of 22 in April, and having winning records every month until September, when they went 12 – 15 and were run down from behind by the Rays. To be honest, they peaked after a long winning streak at 86 – 50, but actually collapsed to the finish line. Had they missed the playoffs, it might have been given the same treatment as a Mets September, but for some reason, the Yankees were given a pass for going 9 – 17 down the stretch.
If I were them, I’d be nervous.
During the season, in addition to the run of the mill waiver claims and what not, the Yankees acquired Austin Kearns for spare parts from Cleveland, later picked up Kerry Wood at the trade deadline for two more minor leaguers, and gave up two decent prospects (Mark Melancon and Jimmy Paredes) to the Astros to pick up Lance Berkman. Wood played pretty well, Kearns was just a backup, and Lance Berkman acted like he wanted to be somewhere else.
The Yankees rotation is led by the remarkable C.C. Sabathia, who provided yet another season as a Cy Young candidate. Philip Hughes took a big step forward by winning 18 decisions in 29 starts, but as a pitcher was just mildly better than the average starter. Andy Pettitte heads to retirement following a remarkably good 21 starts, winning 11 of 14 decisions. However, the #2 starter, A.J. Burnett went 10 – 15 with a 5.26 ERA – 25 runs worse than the average starter over 186.2 innings. And Javier Vazquez was equally poor, despite the 10 – 10 record, with his 5.32 ERA. Vazquez suffered as a flyball pitcher in Yankee Stadium, giving up a homer every fifth inning he pitched. Dustin Moseley and Ivan Nova were tolerable when given chances to start – in fact Nova may earn a rotation spot in 2011.
However, the pitching is thin for 2011 in general. The Yankees twice failed to get Cliff Lee to town (maybe the fans in Yankee Stadium should have been nicer to Lee’s wife). Vazquez is now a Florida Marlin, Andy Pettitte has retired to Texas, and even Kerry Wood returned home (he’s pitching for the Cubs). Sabathia returns, as does Burnett (he HAS to be better than last year), and Hughes will get 32 starts to see if he’s still got the magic. That leaves Ivan Nova, Sergio Mitre, and former rotation stalwarts Bartolo Colon and Freddy Garcia – who are years removed from their better days. I’m not a huge Garcia fan anymore, but he actually was tolerable as a fifth starter for the White Sox last year. On the other hand, he won 12 games in his 28 starts despite a 4.64 ERA, served up a lot of homers, and only struck out 89 in 157 innings. Vazquez came with much better credentials and stunk up the joint. Ivan Nova or Sergio Mitre will have to step forward – and Mitre has enough innings under his belt to suggest he’s not the answer. So that means Nova is likely to get a shot at being the #5 guy.
Mariano Rivera continues to amaze as nears AARP status – a 1.80 ERA, 33 saves, and just 55 base runners in 60 innings. Joba Chamberlain didn’t completely own the 7th or 8th inning, but there are still things to like, including a great K/9 rate and improved control. Boone Logan and Damaso Marte served as solid one-out lefties, and David Robertson was decent in 61.1 innings. Kerry Wood was impressive in his two months.
Looking ahead, Rivera returns for another go, but Rafael Soriano was imported from Tampa to provide an 8th inning ace and potential replacement closer. The rest of the pen contains the familiar faces of Robertson, Logan, and Chamberlain, as well as newly added Pedro Feliciano. Hopefully, these guys are ready for a step up in workload.
Jorge Posada and Francisco Cervelli provided decent enough catching, even if teams ran rampant on Posada when he caught. Posada can still hit some, so he will be moved to the DH role, which means that Cervelli will cede a few innings to Russell Martin. Cervelli is a decent backup – no power, some defense, a fair batting average. Four years ago, Martin was a solid defensive catcher and run producer, that is until Joe Torre ran him into the ground.
The Yankees have an interesting mix of current and aging superstars. At third, you have the declining Alex Rodriguez, who is getting more comfortable at third base as his batting statistics fall off from his MVP level (and steroid supported) play. At short is the captain, Derek Jeter. When he hits .320, Jeter is the most productive shortstop in the AL despite his defensive flaws (range, really, is his only flaw and it’s really getting problematic – so stop giving him the gold glove when he hasn’t ever deserved one). Last year, he hit .270 and the team let him know, through an ugly contract negotiation, that they noticed his decline was both offensive and defensive. At second, you have the remarkably talented Robinson Cano, who is as good a fielder as can be found in the AL and light years ahead of any second sacker when batting, too. At first, you have Mark Teixeira, who struggled to get out April, but still managed 33 homers, 108 RBI, and got on base at a .368 clip. That’s a solid off season. Backing them up is Ramiro Pena, who has little power but some defensive skills – much like Eduardo Nunez, who is the sixth infielder.
I’d like to think that Jeter can bounce back for one more .300 season. If he does, that bodes well for his chances at 3500 hits and the Yankees continuing to make playoff runs. Realistically, that’s not going to happen. Same with Alex Rodriguez, who is barely making 30 homers per year, misses a month of games each year now, and also hit .270 instead of .310. Playing in Yankee Stadium is also masking some of their decline; if Jeter had hit .255 with 7 homers, would anyone give him a chance of a comeback? Cano should be able to duplicate his 2010 season, but last year was a significant step forward to superstardom. And Teixeira will not have another April like last year. The issue is that all four are generally durable (even A-Rod, with his hip, has never missed 60 games in a season) and now, with all but Cano at least two years into their 30s, the chances of someone missing a significant amount of time is going up. I can’t help but think that this is the year – and neither Pena nor Nunez can hit enough to make up for that kind of loss.
The trio of Brett Gardner, Curtis Granderson, and Nick Swisher return after all three provided solid production in 2010. Of the three, Gardner has the greatest chance to produce more in 2011. He could be moved up in the lineup (he should be the leadoff hitter), which would give him more opportunities. Until then, he’s the best centerfielder playing left field on the team, and he’s the best #9 hitter in baseball. Granderson found his power stroke near the end of the year, but he’s only marginally better than average because he doesn’t quite hit .250 anymore. Swisher is coming off a career year in batting and slugging and remains a surprisingly good defensive outfielder. Austin Kearns and Randy Winn are gone (thankfully), but they have imported aging slugger Andruw Jones to help out here and be the right handed counterpart at DH. Greg Golson may be the best defensive option as the alliterative fourth outfielder; Golson or Colin Curtis.
Last year, Marcus Thames was the surprise hit of the team, launching 12 homers in 212 at bats, batting .288, and generating more runs per 27 outs than even Teixeira. In 2011, look for Jorge Posada, Andruw Jones, and one or more of the others (Rodriguez, Swisher, Granderson, or even Jeter to pick up a few at bats here.
Down On the Farm:
It all starts with Jesus Montero, who is an expanded set of defensive skills away from being the next great Yankee catcher. In AAA Scranton/Wilkes Barre, Montero hit for more power, was more selective, and – at 20 – is just about ready. Eduardo Nunez got his first cup of coffee after tying Montero for the team lead in batting, stole 23 bases in 28 attempts, and played a steady shortstop. At 24, he could step in and help out. The top pitcher was Ivan Nova, who went 12 – 3 with a 2.86 ERA, showed good control, and was reasonably solid in his Yankee debut. David Phelps moved up through two levels, going 6 – 0 in 14 starts at AA Trenton, then 4 – 2 in 11 starts at AAA – with great command and a sub 3.00 ERA.
Trenton featured first baseman Brandon Laird, a 23 year old who hit 23 – 90 – .291. Hector Noesi went 8 – 4 with a 1.09 WHIP and an 86/18 K/BB rate. Another pitcher making a step up was Adam Warren, who whipped through three levels since his 2009 draft (4th round), and has been impressive with his command and control at all three levels.
Corbin Joseph was a 4th round pick out of Franklin, TN in 2008 and hit .302 in A+ Tampa. He’s a slight second baseman who seems to be developing a little power as he ages. Another young prospect is Jose Pirela, a Venezuelan burner who plays shortstop and hit 13 triples for Tampa. He may be fighting Joseph for a shot at the second base job in three years. Among the top arms were Pat Venditte (4 – 1, 1.73, 85/14 in 72.2 innings), Dellen Betances – a Brooklyn native who clobbered Tampa opponents (8 – 1, 1.77, 88/19 in 81 innings), and Mexican teen sensation Manny Banuelos, who had 79Ks in 59.2 innings and seems to be ready for a full trip in AA Trenton.
It’s hard to pick against the Yankees because (a) the outfielders are all in their prime, as is Teixeira, and (b) the veterans they have are all still very productive.
On the other hand, this might be the year things fall off. The Yankees won’t be getting MORE production in center or right fields. They won’t be getting MORE production from second base, shortstop, or third base. They won’t be getting MORE production behind the plate. The only spots where improvement might be seen is left field – but that would be at the expense of another position. I think the offense will still be good – but not 859 runs of good. More like 780 runs – a top five offense rather than a #1 offense.
Then you have the defense, which could slip a little at four or five positions. I’d swap Granderson and Gardner, which would help, but you never know if the Yankees would do that since Granderson is only 30. You’d ALMOST want to switch A-ROD and Jeter – but I’m not certain that after the hip surgeries A-ROD can cover short anymore. In fact, nobody in New York can cover short – which makes a lot of the pitchers look worse than they have to. At least Jeter is still solid at turning two.
That brings us to the pitchers. If Sabathia, who came to spring training in WAY better shape than he had been, were to miss any chunk of time, this team could fall off the map. Hughes is good, but not great, Burnett isn’t dependable and is one slump away from being sent to the Pirates or something. Your fourth and fifth starters are rookies or retreads. I think the Yankees will allow a few more runs than in 2010 – maybe 40 more. That puts the team around 780 runs scored and just 725 allowed, which converts to 87 wins. And wait until the Steinbrenner boys see THAT number…