Jason Bay (BOS): Now a Met, I think the Red Sox are going to miss this guy. Had a soft summer, but otherwise was solid. Gets a bad rap for his defense, but last year I showed him as being 5.3 plays per 800 balls in play better than the average left fielder and worthy of a Gold Glove. My system says Bay was one of the 20 most valuable position players in baseball. The Red Sox will move Mike Cameron or Jacoby Ellsbury here – and will lose about 30 runs in total productivity from 2009 to 2010. (109.0 Runs Created, 17.8 Runs Saved = 126.81 Total Run Production)
Carl Crawford (TB): Good hitter, good fielder, as daring a baserunner as you can find. Another top 20 player… Here’s something to think about. Is Carl Crawford potentially worthy of the Hall of Fame? If he can stay healthy, he’d have 2500 career hits and maybe 600 or 700 stolen bases. We put all sorts of power guys in the Hall, but how about a guy who can scoot, hit, and play solid defense? (112.9 Runs Created, 12.5 Runs Saved = 125.36 Total Run Production)
Matt Holliday (OAK/STL): Left town at the trading deadline – was as productive in two months in St. Louis as he was in four months in Oakland… 126.5 Runs Created, -13.4 Runs Saved = 113.1 Total Run Production)
We’ll get to Rajai Davis, your A’s current left fielder in few paragraphs…
Adam Lind (TOR): Miscast as an outfielder, but is such a good hitter he has to play somewhere. The best hitter at this position – Bay’s power and Crawford’s batting average. (127.1 Runs Created, -15.3 Runs Saved = 111.78 Total Run Production)
David DeJesus (KC): A Carl Crawford clone, but a shade less productive – still a valuable player. Crawford hits .300, DeJesus about .280; Both are decent fielders with speed, but DeJesus isn’t a base stealer. (80.9 Runs Created, 18.9 Runs Saved = 99.82 Total Run Production)
Denard Span, the Minnesota outfielder, if he were a regular left fielder would rate here. Jason Kubel, too. I’d love to see Kubel play left every day and let Jim Thome DH as much as possible. The Twins would improve so much offensively…
Johnny Damon (NYY): Now in Detroit, Damon is still a productive hitter as he moves into his late 30s… His legs are getting in the way of his having solid range anymore and he can’t throw. Somebody could use him as a DH and part time outfielder. The new left fielder, Curtis Granderson, was barely two runs more productive than Damon, but since Granderson would be moving to an easier position, he might make up for it with a few more defensive runs. (102.7 Runs Created, -12.3 Runs Saved = 90.38 Total Run Production)
Scott Podsednik (CWS): Now a Royal, played 615 innings here and few hundred more in center… Slapped a few hits, but doesn’t do much else. Can steal a few bases. The Royals hope he’ll be better than what they got for signing Coco Crisp… (81.5 Runs Created, 4.7 Runs Saved, 86.24 Total Run Production)
Juan Rivera (LAA): An above average player – hits for power and a decent average, isn’t hurting you in the field too much. He’s better than Gary Matthews, for sure. (84.0 Runs Created, -3.0 Runs Saved = 80.99 Total Run Production)
Rajai Davis (OAK): He can run, he can field, he can throw a little. Davis can hit .300, but he has little power. If David DeJesus is a poor man’s Carl Crawford, Davis is a poor man’s David DeJesus with younger wheels. Still – he’s an above average performer and with a full season’s at bats, might get 200 hits. (69.1 Runs Created, 2.4 Runs Saved = 71.58 Total Run Production)
Juan Pierre, if he were to be ranked in the AL based on his Dodger stats, would rank here. If the White Sox think he’s a centerfielder, they are grossly mistaken. He’s a combination of Johnny Damon’s defense and Rajai Davis’s offense.
Ryan Rayburn (DET): The Tigers used three people here for the most part (Rayburn, Carlos Guillen, and Josh Anderson) and Rayburn got the most innings. Rayburn has some skills – hits for a nice average with power (.291 BA, .533 SLG, .360 OBP) and looks to have wheels in the outfield. As such, I’d like to see him play more. A full season of Rayburn at this rate would rank in the top five – assuming he can play at this pace for 150 games. (50.7 Runs Created, 14.27 Runs Saved = 64.94 Total Run Production.
David Murphy (TEX): The new Juan Encarnacion. (65.4 Runs Created, -1.1 Run Saved = 64.33 Total Run Production)
Nolan Reimold (BAL): The rookie played great until getting injured in the late summer. Reimold didn’t look comfortable as an outfielder but he got his hitting wheels down as the season rolled on… As with Rayburn, I’d like to see what would happen if he got 500 at bats. Felix Pie isn’t a bad option here, either. (61.9 Runs Created, -5.2 Runs Saved = 56.70 Total Run Production)
Carlos Quentin (CWS): It was only a half a season, but he was still marginally productive. I hope he can get back to where he was in 2008 – the Sox need all the help they can get. (50.9 Runs Created, -3.4 Runs Saved = 47.51 Total Run Production)
Delmon Young (MIN): Delmon Young has done nothing to suggest he deserves a starting position on any roster. Borderline power and batting average, poor fielder. It’s time for the Twins to move on. And, I would NEVER have made that trade with Tampa to get him and give up Jason Bartlett AND Matt Garza. (50.1 Runs Created, -10.2 Runs Saved, 39.90 Total Run Production)
Five Unproductive Guys (SEA): Wladimir Balentien, Bill Hall, Ryan Langerhans, Michael Saunders, and Endy Chavez all got between 175 and 350 innings here and nobody stands out. All five guys were great defensively, oddly, but none of them could hit his way out of a paper sack. Milton Bradley or Eric Byrnes will get the next shot here – and it HAS to be better than what they got last year. At least Bradley can hit – and Byrnes has a great attitude. Combined, they’d be a heck of a player.