Let’s put some of this fun data together and look at the top players by position. Today, we’ll start with the AL First Basemen.
What I have done is taken the basic runs created data (an older Bill James formula modified to account for the park in which that player played) and my defensive runs saved data and combined them into a Total Run Production number. The best players will create the most runs offensively and prevent the most runs defensively.
Kendry Morales (LAA) – Now THAT’S an impact season. You start with the power and average – 34 – 108 – .306. He didn’t walk a lot, but he added more than 40 doubles, too. Morales is also a very mobile first baseman – more mobile than Teixeira. I show him creating about 115 runs of offense and then saving his team about 38 runs defensively. This isn’t the first time that he’s had impressive defensive stats at first. In more than 450 innings there in 2006 he was very good and in 121 innings in 2007 he had similar range numbers. (115.4 Runs Created, 37.8 Runs Saved = 153.20 Total Run Production)
Mark Teixeira (NYY) – It was close, but Morales’ defensive numbers put him over the top. I’m not suggesting that Teixeira is BAD defensively. He’s not. He’s got soft hands and makes many, many impressive plays. However, in the last four years he’s been all over the map. Not so good in Texas, decent in a half season in Atlanta. Then, after a slower start in ATL in 2008, he was very good with the Angels. He was above average last year with the Yankees. As a hitter, Tex was worth 20 more runs, but as a fielder, Morales made up for it with about five runs to spare. I think I’d rather have Tex on my fantasy team, though. (135.6 Runs Created, 12.7 Runs Saved = 148.32 Total Run Production)
Miguel Cabrera (DET) – An alcohol problem surfaced in 2009 and yet he was still very productive. Hopefully, a cleaner Cabrera will have a breakout season in 2010. In 2009, he wasn’t half bad at first base and he remains one of the most productive hitters at any position. I’d draft him. (132.7 Runs Created, 0.9 Runs Saved = 133.62 Total Run Production)
Kevin Youkilis (BOS) – A great fielder at two positions, Boston looks to get more time for Youkilis at first base with Adrian Beltre playing the hot corner. Where the top three guys were all 30 – 100 – .300 types, Youk was 27 – 94 .305 – just a notch below them in power, but just as patient (if not more so) at the plate. (109.6 Runs Created, 14.9 Runs Saved = 124.45 Total Run Production)
Russell Branyan (SEA) – Finally getting a full season of at bats (well, he was injured at the end of the year), Branyan delivered the goods. Solid power and patience, but a lower batting average (.251) than the top tier guys. And, Branyan was surprisingly good at first base, showing well above average range. Seattle turned a negative to a huge positive in 2009. That being said, he still didn’t get to 500 plate appearances and he’s 34. I bet Branyan would like a second shot at his career – but this might have been his best chance and it took forever for someone (Cleveland) to sign him. People must not think he can repeat what he did last year. (81.2 Runs Created, 24.4 Runs Saved = 105.66 Total Run Production)
Paul Konerko (CHI) – The really slow start messed with what was really a pretty good season. Konerko had an average season defensively and a shade more than 90 runs of offense. The issue, of course, is that he’s running out of prime years, turning 34 in Spring Training… (92.5 Runs Created, 7.3 Runs Saved = 99.85 Total Run Production)
Billy Butler (KC) – If you are looking for a sleeper for your fantasy team, you could do worse than drafting this guy… Butler can hit .300 with some power – which will likely get better as he ages. He’s still young and his defense, while not great, wasn’t miserably bad. Personally, I’d rather have Butler than Konerko next year. (103.1 Runs Created, -10.8 Runs Saved = 92.29 Total Run Production.)
Carlos Pena (TB) – Still has world class power (39 homers despite missing a month), but his batting average tanked to .227. He’s NOT a .300 hitter, and I don’t think he’s really a .227 hitter. However, he’s coming off a bad wrist injury and is now 32 (well – he will be in May). His defense is still solid, but it’s not what it once was. Watch how he does in the spring and steal him if he gets off to a decent start. (91.3 Runs Created, .7 Runs Saved = 92.02 Total Run Production)
Lyle Overbay (TOR) – His defense, normally awesome, slipped in 2009. His offense, normally tolerable, slipped in 2009. Overbay isn’t going to hit 20 homers and unless he’s hitting close to .300 and hitting a bunch of doubles and cutting down grounders and line drives to right field, he’s gaining on losing his job to Adam Lind… He might bounce back some, but he’s not high on my draft list. (76.1 Runs Created, -1.8 Runs Saved = 74.31 Total Run Production)
Justin Morneau (MIN) – If healthy, Justin Morneau will likely move back up the list in 2010. However, with stress fractures in his back last year, his batting tanked in the late summer and he couldn’t move well enough in the field. He generated 90 runs of offense (most of it before the All-Star break), which is okay, but he gave 20 back with his defense – hence the low rating. (91.4 Runs Created, -20.51 Runs Saved = 70.92 Total Run Production)
Ryan Garko (CLE) – No longer an Indian, Garko was replaced by Andy Marte after being dealt to San Francisco – and Victor Martinez got several innings here, too. Garko’s net production among two teams was 64.50 (56.5 Runs Created with 8 Runs Saved). The job may well get split again this year among Marte and Travis Hafner. Marte, a long time prospect who turned 26 in the offseason, looked like he hadn’t spent much time there and Victor Martinez looked like a catcher trying to play first base. To be fair, a full season of Garko wouldn’t be horrible – it might be better than having Lyle Overbay these days. Roster Update!!! The Indians signed Russell Branyan to a one-year deal as spring training started – so if Branyan is healthy, the Indians could have a solid answer for 2010.
Aubrey Huff (BAL) – Now plying his trade for San Francisco, Huff had an off season to say the least. Between two teams, Huff’s total production was 58.70 runs (63.8 Runs Created, but -5.1 runs saved). The new first baseman could be Michael Aubrey, a former Indian prospect who has some skills and the same, albeit displaced, name. He’s going to field a little better than Huff and he MIGHT hit pretty well, too. Suffering through injuries in the minor leagues, Baltimore hopes this Aubrey is a late bloomer. God forbid they have to play Garrett Atkins there.
Chris Davis (TEX) – Shared the role with Hank Blalock, none of which is the answer… At least Davis has some range and a little power but he sure does strikeout a lot. If you combine Davis and Blalock, the total production is close to the production of Carlos Pena and his backups… (47.4 Runs Created, 10.1 Runs Saved = 57.44 Total Run Production)
Daric Barton (OAK) – Barton took over for Jason Giambi and wasn’t horrible. He fielded the position well and he gets on base some – though you wish he had a little more power. He’s 70% of Mark Grace, but he’s 24 and has a little room left to grow… The A’s could choose to go with Eric Chavez here if they let Kevin Kouzmanoff play third base all season. Barton also serves as the emergency catcher, having started his career as a catcher out of high school.
Quick Notes… Having done this, the median starting first baseman in the AL produced about 92 runs for his team and the replacement level would have been about 70 runs of production. The latter seems a little low in that Minnesota’s final number, if you included the time spent at first base by Michael Cuddyer, would have been closer to 85 or 90 runs. So, more realistically, your first basemen have to generate at least 90 runs of production lest they need to be replaced. Morales and Teixeira were, in essence, about six wins better than the average first baseman.