2011 Record: 71 – 91 (5th, NL Central)
Runs Scored: 654 (8th, NL)
Runs Allowed: 756 (14th, NL)
Only Colorado and Houston allowed more runs…
2011 in Review:
The Cubs started losing early, and pretty much were consistent about it throughout the season. Starlin Castro kept hitting all year long, but the team was lacking in production from the outfield and the catcher spot. Carlos Zambrano was extremely frustrated and threatened to retire – but considering his history of blow ups, the Cubs shut him down anyway. The Cubs really had little truly decent pitching, helped by a defense that had little range and made a lot of errors. When it was over, Chicago was under new ownership. That group finally let Jim Hendry go – Hendry was the GM who was responsible for this mess – and replaced him with the Boston Red Sox mastermind, Theo Epstein. At least the Cubs have THAT going for them.
Matt Garza was acquired from Tampa and battled things to a draw. He finished 10 – 10, his ERA looks good here, but it’s masked somewhat by the 17 unearned runs he allowed. In terms of runs allowed per nine, he was barely league average. Ryan Dempster‘s season was particularly troublesome. His strikeout rate was pretty good, but he walked more than in the past and he gave up too many homers. Zambrano, Randy Wells, Casey Coleman, Rodrigo Lopez, and Doug Davis were all at least 10 runs worse than the average pitcher given the number of innings pitched. Here’s the breakdown:
Runs Saved /Pitcher
1.81 Matt Garza (31 starts)
-10.71 Rodrigo Lopez (16 starts)
-12.45 Carlos Zambrano (24 starts)
-13.24 Randy Wells (24 starts)
-16.82 Doug Davis (9 starts – ouch)
-17.17 Ryan Dempster (34 starts)
-22.88 Casey Coleman (17 starts)
Essentially, the starters gave up 90 runs more than an average pitcher would have done in the same amount of innings.
For 2012, Dempster and Garza are back. Zambrano was traded to the Marlins for starter Chris Volstad, but that’s not an improvement – Volstad pitched worse than Zambrano last year. Jeff Samardzija is being moved to the rotation – he was one of the few Cubs pitchers to pitch on the good side of average. If he can match that for 180 innings instead of 90 innings, that would be a huge improvement over, say, Casey Coleman and Rodrigo Lopez. If Wells can stay healthy and get back, that would help, too. One can see a 40 run improvement at this spot.
Carlos Marmol has been a closer for a few years now, and he isn’t getting any better. A closer with an ERA over 4 is a problem – and he’s so wild that he’s allowing nearly six walks every nine innings. The set up squad was actually pretty good – Samardzija was nearly six runs better than the average pitcher; Sean Marshall was even better – the best pitcher on the staff (14 runs saved). Kerry Wood was tolerable, but is running out of innings in his arm. After that, though, you run through some guys who struggled – John Grabow and James Russell.
Looking forward, I’m scared here. The best pitcher, Sean Marshall, is gone. Samardzija is in the rotation. The Cubs could be relying on Coleman to take on a long relief role, or pulling in Rafael Dolis or Chris Carpenter. I’m worried that this unit could easily be 10 – 15 runs worse than 2011.
As a unit, Geovany Soto and Koyie Hill were fair against the run and mobile. On the other hand, they were mistake prone and if they are to get some responsibility for the pitching staff, the team was 20 games under .500 with a lousy overall ERA.
Soto can hit a little, but he’s been inconsistent with his batting average and power. Soto finished by hitting .228 with 17 homers, which really isn’t good enough – especially in Wrigley Field. Hill was worse – .194 with sub .300 slugging and on base percentages.
I made a comment that the team defense wasn’t very good in 2011 – that doesn’t apply to the middle infielders here. Shortstop Starlin Castro saved the team 18 runs – which breaks down to 24 runs because of his range, but he gives back nearly six runs because of his errors. Darwin Barney was also mobile and slightly error prone, but the net result was another 14 runs saved. The play on the corners, though, featured two older guys who no longer have the range to help out. Carlos Pena was once a fine fielder – not anymore. He cost the team 19 runs. Aramis Ramirez was even worse – he cost the Cubs 36 runs. Granted, the offense here isn’t half bad. Barney has room to improve – he needs to be more selective at the plate and get his batting average up to the .290 range. Castro had 207 hits and generated 108 runs of offense, but he makes a lot of outs. Ramirez had a nice season – 109 runs created, and Pena added 85 more, despite hitting just .225 (he drew 101 walks and hit 28 homers). That kind of production will be hard to replace.
The Cubs will try Bryan Lahair, the minor league home run champ, at first base. His fielding isn’t sterling, but his bat can help. Ian Stewart was acquired from Colorado and he’s going to hit better than the .156 he hit in 2011, but he’s NOT going to be the run producer that Ramirez was. Castro may still have more growth in him, as will Barney, but this unit could easily be down 50 runs from last year.
The Cubs featured an outfield of Alfonso Soriano, who has below average range, Marlon Byrd, who is surprisingly mobile for an older guy – but still below average in terms of range, and, for three months, Kosuke Fukudome. Fukodome has great range for a right fielder. Tyler Colvin replaced him, but he fell off the map in terms of his offensive output.
Offensively, Soriano still has power – 26 homers – but he doesn’t run and he still is too much of a free swinger. Byrd seems to have lost all of his power and he, too, stopped getting on base after getting hit in the face with a pitch in Boston last May. Colvin hit .150 – ouch! The Cubs never seemed satisfied with Fukudome, yet he was actually the most productive hitter in the outfield.
Colvin is gone – he’s in Colorado – but Soriano isn’t going anywhere soon, and Byrd needs to get out of center and move to right so that the young legs of Tony Campana can take over in center. Reed Johnson (he’s still around?) played well – he needed to play more. The problem is that the Cubs don’t have someone who can help immediately.
The AAA Iowa Cubs were devoid of young prospects who can help soon… The aforementioned Bryan Lahair hit 38 – 109 – .331, but was 28 last year. The best player to roll through here that was younger might be catcher Wellington Castillo , a 24-year-old who looks no better or worse than Geovany Soto, and Tony Campana, who was here for just 30 games and hit .342 – a burner with little or no power. Casey Coleman was the best pitcher, but even he had holes – he doesn’t have a big strikeout pitch and he gave up 11 homers in 70 innings.
There may be help in AA, though – the Tennessee Smokies were a top flight minor league team. Josh Vitters, a former #1 pick (2007) and Rebel Ridling – a great name – hit enough and with some power to suggest that they might get a shot by the end of 2012. 2008 #1 pick Ryan Flaherty hit pretty well, but he’s a shortstop and middle infielders are pretty set in Chicago. He might get used in a deal soon – him or his fellow middle infielder D.J. LeMahieu… The pitcher who had results was reliever Jeff Beliveau – who sounds like he should be a hockey player – 57 innings, 69 Ks and just 13 walks. Kevin Rhoderick has a stunning arm but needs to refine his control. Jeff Stevens had good numbers here, but he’s already turning 28 soon and has had a cup of coffee…
A+ Daytona finished second in the Florida State League and first baseman Justin Bour led the team in homers and RBIs – hitting 23 homers in the FSL is legit power. Undrafted Junior Lake continued to play well – is turning 22 and hit over .300 with some power and great speed. One thing you notice when looking over the pitching staff is a lack of high draft picks – the best pitcher was undrafted Jeff Antiqua, who logged 83.1 innings, fanned 81, and walked just 18.
If there is help on the way, it might be catcher Richard Jones, who hit 24 homers and batted .309 for low A Peoria. It doesn’t look like it will be #1 pick Hayden Simpson, who fell off to 1 – 6 – 5.32. The best arm might belong to 11th round pick Eric Jokisch, who went 9 – 3 with a good K/W ratio in 118.2 innings.
The Cubs will probably allow 30 fewer runs this year – it can’t really get worse than 2011 – but the offense looks worse. If the team falls back another 50 runs, which is entirely possible, you’re looking at a 66 – 96 team. If Stewart doesn’t come back and Soriano falls off, and LeHair doesn’t hit in the majors, the Cubs are looking at 100 losses. Theo Epstein has a lot of work to do.