Record – Last Five Years:
2012: 61 – 101
2011: 71 – 91
2010: 75 – 87
2009: 83 – 78
2008: 97 – 64
Record at Home: 38 – 43
Record at Home: 23 – 58 (ouch)
Runs Scored: 613 (14th in NL)
Runs Allowed: 759 (14th in NL)
This is still going in the wrong direction.
Ultimately, the team was awful out the gate, and continued playing poorly into May, including a long losing streak in late May (12 games). Something clicked in late June and July – from 6/25 to 7/30, the Cubs went from 24-48 to 43-58, a nice run of 19 wins in 29 games. Sadly, that was the high point – from that point forward, the Cubs had just a single good week in the last two months of the season. When they played the Astros to end the season, it was the first time in nearly 50 years that two teams with 100 losses appeared in the same game(s).
Record By Month:
Apr: 8 – 15
May: 10 – 17
Jun: 10 – 17
Jul: 15 – 10
Aug: 8 – 21
Sep: 9 – 19
Oct: 1 – 2
The bad news is that the Astros are no longer in the NL Central, so if the Cubs want to avoid last place, they actually have to get better…
The rotation, save a couple of spots, wasn’t the problem. Jeff Samardzija was an above average option, going 9 – 13 thanks to a lack of run support. Travis Wood wasn’t horrible, and neither was Paul Maholm (9 – 6 in 20 starts). Ryan Dempster was great until he was sent to the AL, while Matt Garza was decent until he got sent to the DL. The two problems were Chris Volstad, who was predictably horrible (3 – 12, 6.31) and rookie Justin Germano (2 – 10, 6.75).
Heading into 2013, the Cubs won’t have Maholm either – he’s a Brave. However, the Cubs did import the well-traveled Edwin Jackson who should be an innings-eater, if nothing else. Samardzija returns as the ace (and he is getting better), and the bottom of the rotation will include Scott Feldman from Texas and Carlos Villanueva, a former Brewer and Blue Jay arm. Feldman was not very successful in Texas (11 runs worse than average in about 135 innings), but Villanueva wasn’t half bad in 125 innings. The question is can either of these guys get to 180 innings. If Garza can come back and help at all, the rotation looks to be no worse than last year with the efforts to improve the slot where Feldman takes over for Volstad offset by the lack of anyone who can pitch as well as Dempster did before he left.
One of the biggest problems in Chicago lately has been the lack of a dependable closer – Carlos Marmol has no idea how to control his pitches and he walks people all day until he serves up a homer. Even at that, his runs allowed rate is marginally above average. Shawn Camp was pretty good, James Russell is a better reliever than starter, and former Sox arm Michael Bowden did okay. The problem is that the rest of the relievers are below average.
The Cubs will give a shot to a couple of Asian imports, Kyuji Fujikawa and Hisanori Takahashi. Both can be better than what the Cubs had, but aren’t really proven commodities. If Marmol continues to deteriorate and the imports (and Camp) take a step back, this could be a devastating problem.
Goodbye Geovany Soto, and hello to the Wellington Castro era. Dioner Navarro has been brought in to help out. Cubs catching was well below average compared to the rest of the NL (bad against the running game, bad at winning games, bad at preventing runs from scoring, slightly error prone). Castillo wasn’t better than Soto, but he did hit better than Soto had. The problem is that Navarro may hit like Soto did last year.
Anthony Rizzo was a solid addition at first base and only has room to improve. Darwin Barney and Starlin Castro are the best keystone combination in the majors defensively – they hit some, too. The problem is that the third base slot isn’t being filled well by either Luis Valbuena or Ian Stewart. This is a significant hole – and Josh Vitters doesn’t look ready to fill it. The Cubs miss Aramis Ramirez. A full season of Rizzo looks like the only opportunity for improvement over last year.
Alfonso Soriano had a reasonably good year in left – better as a defender, believe it or not, and as an expensive option, likely isn’t going anywhere. David DeJesus is okay as a number two hitter, but not a great centerfielder. He’s also getting older. In right, the Cubs trade Bryan LeHair for former Giant Nate Schierholtz, which isn’t a step forward. I see this group falling off from last season’s stats both offensively and defensively.
Alberto Gonzalez and Brett Lillibridge are around, as is Scott Hairston, who is an able bodied pinch hitter and fourth outfielder. Other than Hairston, I’m not impressed.
DOWN ON THE FARM:
AAA Iowa Outfielder David Sappelt didn’t do much and got a job out of spring training, which scares me. Josh Vitters hit .304 at Iowa with some power, but didn’t impress at the major league level – he will get another chance. Rizzo killed AAA and made the big leagues. None of the starters were impressive, even though Chris Rusin got a cup of coffee – the best relievers, like Bowden and Scott Maine, were given shots with the big club.
The AA Tennessee Smokies didn’t have a single batter clear .300 who played regularly, but Justin Bour wasn’t horrible – some power, a bit of a free swinger. The best arm may be Nicholas Struck, who is 22, fanned 123 and walked just 44 in 155.2 innings and had a winning record. Eric Jokisch looked okay in 17 starts, but needs to find a strikeout pitch to advance and be productive.
Daytona (A+) has 2011 first round pick Javier Baez to look forward to – but he’s a shorstop who may have to be traded for other options. John Andreoli isn’t horrible, a good eye, great speed, but no power. Young arms may help, though, including Matt Loosen and Frank Del Valle. Unfortunately, 2010 first round pick Hayden Simpson may be done.
I don’t see a reason to be optimistic. The team crashed down the stretch, they didn’t make any significant changes to the roster, and the one area where the team could improve (first base) is going to be offset by the outfield getting another year older and less productive. This team looks to finish about 65 – 97 and are an injury to Rizzo or Castro from losing 105 games. Theo – it’s about time for your first miracle, wouldn’t you think?