Rather than rank them, I’ll just sort by team – especially since some teams didn’t really have a standard DH (Detroit, for example).
Baltimore: Luke Scott got 89 games, the rest were mixed. Scott is an above average offensive player with legitimate power and enough patience to help out (55 walks in 128 games). Scott is not really an outfielder, but he can back people up in right field if required. (73.3 Runs Created)
Boston: David Ortiz played 139 games. We know about his horrible first two months, but he finished strong – 28 homers and 99 RBI. I don’t think he can rebound to being a .300/.400/.550 guy again, but if he gets off to a quicker start and hits close to .260, he’ll remain valuable. (81.0 Runs Created)
Chicago: Jim Thome played 98 games before being traded… Still a great hitter and the Twins will like him. Is Carlos Quentin the first choice in 2010? Thome was productive – more so than Ortiz per 27 outs, but played far fewer games. (61.7 Runs Created)
Cleveland: Travis Hafner played 88 games… He and the Indians are still recovering. The rest were shared amongst the other teammates. Hafner may never hit 25 homers again… (61.6 Runs Created)
Detroit: Didn’t really have a regular – Marcus Thames got 50 games, Carlos Guillen 33, Aubrey Huff 28 brutally bad games down the stretch. Magglio Ordonez should have the job because he’s been an immobile object in right for several years now.
Kansas City: Mike Jacobs got the bulk of the work – 102 games – and it was crushingly unproductive. 49 Runs Created, less than four runs per 27 outs. There just weren’t a whole lot of better options – the team needs to add DEPTH and add it fast. (49.0 Runs Created)
Los Angeles: Vladimir Guerrero stayed healthy enough for 93 games, the rest were split among friends… Vlad is now in Texas, but I would be concerned about his health, as his body is breaking down after a rather long and productive career. Even last year, falling off as a hitter, he was still productive. Hideki Matsui‘s job now… (58.7 Runs Created)
Minnesota: Jason Kubel got half, Joe Mauer used the position for his bat and resting his back… As a hitter, Kubel was the second most productive of the DH regulars. (98.1 Runs Created)
New York: Hideki Matsui‘s primary job – 116 games. Kubel may have created more runs, but Matsui created more runs per 27 outs (7.0). Now an Angel, if he can stay healthy he’d still be productive even with losing 10 – 20% of his skills. (87.0 Runs Created)
Oakland: Jack Cust got 96 games, Jason Giambi – while in town – got 22 more. Nomar Garciaparra also got 22 games here. Cust struck out 36% of the time – a frightening number – and yet had a .359 OBP and created runs. (78.5 Runs Created)
Seattle: Ken Griffey‘s last job as a Mariner. Mike Sweeney was his platoon partner. They combined for 27 homers and 91 RBI – but the net batting average and OBP was rather pedestrian.
Tampa: Pat (The Bat) Burrell‘s job 112 times, otherwise Willy Aybar. Aybar was better… When Burrell signed, I don’t think 14 – 64 – .221 was what they had in mind. (48.5 Runs Created)
Texas: Andruw Jones and Hank Blalock split 100 games, the rest were dished out with Julio Borbon getting 21 shots. Nobody really helped the cause, which is why Vlad Guerrero was added to the roster.
Toronto: Adam Lind, a born DH, was here 92 times. Randy Ruiz got 30, and the rest were shared… Lind was the best hitter of the bunch – 36 – 108 – .305. He’ll play outfield from time to time, but in a few years, he’ll be Jim Thome for sure. Randy Ruiz was just as good in his shot – 10 homers in 115 at bats and batted .313.