Last Five Years:
2010: 66 – 96 (Last in AL East)
2009: 64 – 98
2008: 68 – 93
2007: 69 – 93
2006: 70 – 92
The Orioles haven’t had a winning record since 1997, when the roster included Rafael Palmeiro, Robbie Alomar, Cal Ripken, and Brady Anderson, with Harold Baines and Eric Davis on the bench. The rotation was Mussina, Erickson, Jimmy Key, and Scott Kamieniecki. Randy Myers was the closer and Jesse Orosco, Armando Benitez, and Arthur Rhodes were in the bullpen. Oh, and Jeffrey Maier got in the way…
Runs Scored: 613 (13th in the AL, 100 runs better than Seattle, but well below average)
Runs Allowed: 785 (13th in the AL, 60 runs better than the Royals, but well below average)
2010 in Review:
A lot was made out of the hiring of Buck Showalter, and the early results were admittedly stunning.
The Dave Trembley managed Orioles were picked by many to finish last or fourth in the AL and didn’t disappoint. The young arms didn’t get started, and the bats never came around. Baltimore started 5 – 18, won just 10 in May, and went 9 – 17 in June. By then, Trembley had been relieved of his job and Juan Samuel was given the interim job. Things didn’t get any better, as the Orioles went 8 – 19 in July. With a record of 32 – 73 (!), having just been swept by the Royals, the Orioles were pacing for just 49 wins – an historically bad total – so Buck Showalter was brought in to add organization and teaching to the Orioles. The Orioles had a winning record in August and September (and October, 3 – 1). This 34 – 23 stretch was NOT built, like the White Sox, Minnesota, and Detroit win streaks, by beating up on the lower level teams in the AL or a run of games against the NL Central, but rather against the AL East and other good teams like Texas, Chicago, Anaheim, and Detroit.
The roster moved around mostly because young players were shuttled in and out, but the Orioles had tried bringing in Miguel Tejada, and then sent him packing to San Diego before the trading deadline. The other minor deal the Orioles did was to trade Will (Suitcase) Ohman to the Marlins for fringe rotation starter Rick Vanden Hurk.
Jeremy Guthrie had a pretty solid year – 3.83 ERA, 209.1 innings, doesn’t walk people but served up a few homers. His strikeout rate is a bit low, which is disconcerting, but not yet problematic. Behind him was the disappointing import Kevin Millwood. Millwood went 4 – 16 with a 5.10 ERA, mostly because he gave up 30 homers. He actually struck out more guys than Guthrie with decent control, but you can’t give up 30 dingers without absorbing losses… The third starter, Brian Matusz, showed promise finishing 10 – 12 with even better K/9 rates, and a better than league average run rate. Brad Bergesen made 28 starts and was a young Kevin Millwood – lots of homers, without the good K rate. The fifth slot was shared by youngsters Jake Arrieta and Chris Tillman. Arrieta is a prospect but had nearly as many walks as strikeouts, which isn’t very good, and Tillman is a 22-year-old prospect who had very similar numbers to Arrieta – actually finishing with the same number of walks to strikeouts. Arrieta and Tillman had replaced David Hernandez, who was lousy in the rotation but decent as a reliever.
Looking forward to 2011, the only change is the dismissal of Millwood, and the possible addition of Justin Duchscherer as a fifth starter option. Duchscherer lost 2009 to surgery on his left elbow, battled depression, and came back in 2010 only to miss most of that season to have surgery on his left hip. What would help the rotation most would be to keep the ball in the park, and for the middle defense to get stronger… And, it would be nice to have a true ACE at the top of the rotation, which would slot Guthrie, Matusz, and Bergesen one spot down the chain.
Alfredo Simon failed as the closer, ceding the job to Koji Uehara. Uehara is a good late inning option, finishing with 55 Ks and just 5 walks in 43 innings. Will Ohman was tolerable, Matt Albers wasn’t, and Mike Gonzalez – a good reliever – couldn’t stay healthy. Mark Hendrickson may have played himself out of baseball, and Jason Berken may have played his way into an eighth inning role. On the whole, though, the bullpen was lacking an ace as well. Berken or Uehara could BECOME an ace, but until then, the Orioles brought in Kevin Gregg to be the closer for at least four months… (He seems to run out of gas in August, and I can’t explain that since he’s a reliever, but he’s got John Franco disease.) Gregg can be much better than Alfredo Simon, and if Mike Gonzalez can pitch 50 innings, there is hope that the bullpen can be ten to fifteen runs better than in 2010.
Matt Wieters is a good young catcher. I don’t know if he will be the next Joe Mauer, but he can be 80% of Joe Mauer and that’s not half bad. Defensively, he’s pretty solid with a strong arm. Offensively, he wasn’t all that great, but I wouldn’t be surprised if he jumped from the 11 – 55 – .249 numbers of 2010 to 17 – 75 – .280 in 2011. I saw him in the minors and he’s BIG – 6′ 5″ and 225, and there is something about him that is impressive. Let’s hope he takes that step forward. Jake Fox and Craig Tatum are backups. Fox can hit some – but doesn’t have a defensive position (why can’t he just DH?) and Tatum hit singles and catches the ball, but didn’t throw out any base stealers in 2010. Okay, two.
Most of last year’s infield is gone. Instead of Ty Wiggington playing everywhere (and well) – usually at first base, Brian Roberts at second, Cesar Izturis at short, and Miguel Tejada at third, you have a much different, and potentially stronger offensive lineup.
Look, Tejada played third very well but his offense is slipping (as you would expect), and he was traded to San Diego. Izturis fell off both offensively and defensively, and Brian Roberts couldn’t stay healthy, forcing Julio Lugo or Robert Andino into more regular roles. Garrett Atkins was given a shot and, as I mentioned, shouldn’t have been given that shot. On the whole, though, the infield in 2010 was WEAK.
Looking at 2011, you have Mark Reynolds, the basher who arrives from Arizona with a need to get his batting average back over .230 and cut his strikeouts down to under, say, 200. STILL, even hitting .198, his power and walks make him an above average hitter and his defense is surprisingly strong. J.J. Hardy comes over from Minnesota for prospects and immediately upgrades the offense and actually did a better job than Izturis in the field in 2010. (I like Hardy as a late round fantasy pick – coming off a left wrist injury, his power should return – especially here.) Izturis remains as a utility infielder along with Robert Andino. Brian Roberts should be the DH because his body is breaking down and his defense has never been really good. But, if he played 130 games at second, he might score 100 runs and few guys can do that. Covering first base is newcomer Derrek Lee. I’m not a huge fan of this – he’s getting old, his back doesn’t allow him to get to ground balls anymore, and he’s coming off of right thumb surgery – and I’d rather have kept Wigginton. Luke Scott is his short term backup… Still, there is a really good chance that the defense will be no worse than last year and the offense could jump up 60 – 80 runs better than last year.
Two positions remain capably covered, with Adam Jones being one of the most productive centerfielders in the AL, and Nick Markakis playing a reliable if not insanely productive right field. Markakis could have a breakout season, but he sure hits fewer homers than he used to. It would be nice if he accidentally tagged 25 homers, but I wouldn’t bet on it. Luke Scott plays left, with Felix Pie getting at bats and logging late defensive innings. It’s not a horrible platoon, really. The fifth outfielder, Nolan Reimold, is better than his injury riddled numbers in 2011.
Luke Scott gets at bats here, as does Jake Fox, but in 2011, the Orioles have added Vlad Guerrero. Guerrero had a decent first half in 2010, but faded badly down the stretch. Oddly, the Orioles have a lot of candidates to play here and if they wanted someone on the Rangers, I’d gladly take Michael Young to play second and move Roberts to DH before I’d have given a deal to Guerrero. Vlad got a one-year deal, though, so hopefully it will pay off.
Down on the Farm:
Most of what can play is already with the big club, leaving the top end of the minors system for Baltimore a bit thin. The best players on the Norfolk Tides (AAA) were pitchers Jake Arrieta and Chris Tillman, who are pretty decent prospects, and catcher Brandon Snyder, who doesn’t have a place to play so long as Matt Wieters is still around.
Joel Guzman is still around, hitting 33 homers at AA Bowie. A few years ago, Guzman was considered a propsect at SS because he was mobile and had power. He’s still got power, but he’s older and heavier (and taller) and now he’s trying to make it back to the bigs but he might have to do it as a third baseman. God bless him… Ryan Adams was taken #2 five years ago, and looked like an almost prospect at Bowie – but mid-range power hitting .298 isn’t going to make it much past a cup of coffee. Joe Mahoney seems to be making progress, hitting for more power and higher averages as he works through the minors. He’ll likely start in Bowie, though, and for a first baseman mid-range power isn’t a total asset.
Speaking of first basemen with mid-range power… Tyler Townsend, taken in the third round in 2009, looks like a Gaby Sanchez-type hitter in A+ Frederick. If he takes a step forward in 2011, look for him to make the squad in late 2013. Former #2 pick, Mychal Givens is returning from a thumb injury, it will be interesting to see what the shortstop can do if he can just play a full season at Delmarva or A+ Frederick.
The Orioles made a lot of bold changes to the roster, most of which will bolster the offense. I mean, this is a pretty good lineup: Roberts, Markakis, Jones, Scott, Reynolds, Vlad, Lee, Wieters and Hardy. This team could easily jump from 613 runs scored to 725 or even 740 runs. It could also struggle for three months if Vlad and Lee can’t get on track and finish at around 675. I like the idea, however, that 700 runs is very possible. The team isn’t GREAT defensively as long as Roberts and Hardy are your double-play combination, but the problem in 2010 was homers allowed more than anything else.
The pitching will hold steady in the rotation, but the bullpen could be marginally better. Facing Boston, Tampa, New York, and Toronto, it’s hard to look great with your pitching staff. That being said, I don’t know if the Yankees and Tampa will score more than 800 runs in 2011, and that will help lower the Baltimore defensive numbers. It’s VERY possible that the AL East may have five teams at or above .500 at some point in the season. Baltimore isn’t going to win 85 games, but they have a very good shot at 80 wins. Realistically, I see them as a 79 – 83 team, getting the fans excited about the Orioles future.
I also see them having some big holes to fill in 2012 – first base, second base, closer, and ace – that will require the farm to turn out a future star or the ownership to make a REALLY bold move rather than fetch a bunch of veterans as short gap changes.