Last Five Seasons:
2010: 94 – 68 (Winners of the AL Central, losers to the Yankees in the playoffs… Again.)
2009: 87 – 76
2008: 88 – 75
2007: 79 – 83
2006: 96 – 66
This has been a great run for a well-managed franchise.
Runs Scored: 781 (5th in the AL)
Runs Allowed: 671 (3rd in the AL)
With this combination, the Twins would be expected to win 93.2 games – right about where they finished.
At the outset, the Twins were considered among the favorites to win the division, and having tossed aside the White Sox whenever they needed to, held off Chicago to walk away with the division for the third time and fourth in five seasons.
The Twins came out strong in April, winning 15 of 23. They held serve in May, but when the Sox got hot in the summer, the Twins had their worst month in June. This ended in July, however, as the Twins got stronger every month and looked like a potential World Series team until they faced the Yankees in the playoffs.
Among the hardships – Justin Morneau took a knee to the head while sliding into second base against the Blue Jays and missed the last three months of the season at a time when the first baseman was hitting like Ted Williams. And, closer Joe Nathan went down after one spring training appearance, missing the season following Tommy John surgery.
The Twins made a few moves to shore up the bullpen after Nathan’s injury, acquiring Matt Capps from Washington in July, and later picking up Brian Fuentes from the Angels in September – in both cases for essentially spare parts.
Francisco Liriano put his career back on track in 2010, winning a rotation slot in the spring and then winning 14 games and striking out 201 batters during the season. This, as much as anything, gave the Twins a needed shot in the arm as the season started. Carl Pavano had an even better 2010 than 2009, pitching 221 innings, hardly walking anyone at all (just 37) and winning 17 games. Kevin Slowey went 13 – 6 despite pitching at essentially league average levels, but also doesn’t walk anybody (29 in 155.2 innings). Same goes for Scott Baker (12 – 9, 43 walks in 170.1 innings) and the less effective Nick Blackburn (40 walks in 161 innings). Swingman Brian Duensing was a team MVP candidate, making 13 starts amongst his 53 appearances, winning 10 of 13 decisions, and finishing with a 2.62 ERA. Duensing also has great control.
All this is good – but a long-time reader of Bill James might notice something particularly troubling. One of his predictors of future success (or decline) is looking at the ratio of strikeouts to wins. Pavano won 17 with only 117 strikeouts – so he’d be expected to decline to something like 8 – 11. Blackburn, already well below average with his 5.42 ERA, won 10 and fanned just 68. He might expect to go 5 – 7. Kevin Slowey won 13 and fanned just 116. He’s a candidate to fall to 10 – 10 or something like that. Liriano and Baker are probably good candidates to hold steady, with good strikeout rates.
Perhaps the really high control guys can get away with this more than other pitchers because fewer guys are getting on base. Still – I’d be a bit nervous about this. Likely Duensing will get more starts than Blackburn in 2011.
When Joe Nathan went down, Jon Rauch became the first closer. He was okay – not great, though – so the Twins picked up Matt Capps for the rest of the way – and he was fantastic. There are other quality relievers around, too. Jose Mijares is a decent late inning option, as is the returning Pat Neshak, with Alex Burnett picking up long relief. Jeff Manship and Glen Perkins will battle for the other slots in the pen. I think, however, that the Twins will miss Rauch, Jesse Crain (3.04 ERA in 71 appearances) and Matt Guerier (3.17 ERA, 74 appearances), and even Ron Mahay (3.44 ERA in 41 appearances). Manager Ron Gardenhire will have to work a little magic here.
Joe Mauer remains the best catcher in baseball, despite having a season that was well below his career breakout season of 2009. Mauer is fighting bum knees and a sore back and will eventually turn into a first baseman or DH before too long. For now, Mauer is solid defensively against the run, works well with this staff, and doesn’t make many errors. Drew Butera is his less than tolerable backup.
Morneau’s injury has already been covered – as a hitter, he’s remarkable and as a fielder he has little range. After sitting out for three months (and much of the early spring), here’s hoping he can get back and play 150 games this year. If not, the Twins will move Michael Cuddyer back to first base. Cuddyer is better in terms of range, but can’t hit like Morneau. Last year, the Twins had the second best second baseman in the AL in Orlando Hudson. This year, the Twins imported switch hitting Tsuyoshi Nishioka to play second. Nishioka won the batting title in Japan last year, has gap power and blazing speed. The new shortstop will likely be Alexi Casilla, who played well in a utilty role last year. I like Casilla a little, but I’m not certain his defensive skills will make up for his not being as good an offensive player as J.J. Hardy. At third will be rookie Danny Valencia, who came up and did a nice job replacing the injured and ineffective Brendan Harris. Trevor Plouffe and Matt Tolbert will replace former utility player Nick Punto, who joins the Cardinals.
Delmon Young had a breakout season offensively, but can’t seem to run down anything in the field when playing in left. Denard Span has solid defensive skills and occasionally hits like a leadoff hitter. Last year, not so much, but the Twins survived anyway. In right, Jason Kubel or Michael Cuddyer will get the bulk of the action. Both are slightly above average hitters and barely tolerable fielders. Jason Repko is a pretty good fourth outfield option, and Ben Revere might gallop onto the roster and take the #5 slot.
The 40-year-old Jim Thome had a remarkably productive season in 2010 and will return for another go in 2011. When getting a day off, look for Cuddyer or Kubel to take at bats.
Down on the Farm:
My son, Casey, is playing on his first little league team and it’s fashioned after the Rochester Red Wings. We use their hat; their tee-shirt is our uniform. I’ll be ordering a hat later today. But if you are looking at THIS Red Wings team and not ours, you’d be a little concerned. Most of the guys who can play some and played in Rochester have already arrived. Danny Valencia is now your regular third baseman, Trevor Plouffe (a low average hitter with some power) got a cup of coffee and may be the utility infielder. One of the regulars on this team, I was surprised to see, was corner outfielder Jacque Jones. Yeah – THAT Jacque Jones… The Red Wings hitters were a little light, and the pitchers – mostly the starters – weren’t very good. The one arm that impressed me was Anthony (Phi) Slama, who saved 17 games, fanned 74 in 65.1 innings, and allowed just 41 hits. Oh – since I mentioned that Jacque Jones was still playing, I should note that Mike Maroth logged 11 innings in AAA as well here.
Ben Revere is a centerfielder who got a cup of coffee after hitting .305 in AA New Britain; he’s a burner with no power – and that lack of power also means a lack of triples, even for a guy who stole 36 bases in 94 games. He’s the new Matty Alou, I guess. Joe Benson hit 23 homers, can run a little, and is just 23. The power was a surprise, he had 23 homers in his previous four seasons and 21 games of A+ ball in 2010. If this is a legitimate change in his skill set, he’ll get to the majors in a couple of years.
The pitcher in this group I really want to see is reliever Billy Bullock – the third round pick from 2008 out of Florida. In 36.2 innings, he struck out 60 batters. 60! He walked 24 guys, must be wild as all get out, but WOW that’s an impressive number. The Twins moved Deolis Guerra up from AA to AAA at the end of 2010 – after a year he went 2 – 10 with a 6.24 ERA. I don’t get that. He’s young and must have amazing stuff.
A couple of pitchers catch your eye at A+ Fort Myers. Bruce Pugh was just 7 – 10, but he struck out 106 in 102.2 innings and allowed just 81 hits. Reliever Liam Hendriks fits the Minnesota control mode – in 74.2 innings, his K/W ratio was 66/8. Another reliever there, Bobby Lanigan, was 41/7 in 54.1 innings. As such, a guy named Shooter Hunt probably won’t make it – walking 84 in 67.1 innings with 19 wild pitches. He also struck out 79 in 67.1 innings – so he must have an amazing arm. In 2008, he was a first round draft pick, but he’s still figuring things out.
I see too many reasons for the Twins to take a step back in 2011, and won’t pick them to repeat. I know the new Target Field gets in the way of people having great offensive seasons and helps the pitchers. However, I think three of the six starting pitchers will fall back and fall back a lot. The bullpen doesn’t seem as deep as in 2010. Nishioka could be a revelation, but Orlando Hudson was really good last year. If Nishioka is that good, it’s just a wash. Valencia played well, but is already 26 – so he’s a bit long in the tooth to have a long and successful career. Mauer is starting to accumulate wear and tear and his knees are already problematic. Jim Thome turns 41 in August.
The offense is going to fall back some – the question is how much, and depends in large part how much Delmon Young falls back, Mauer or Thome fall back, and how Morneau returns. I think the Twins will be lucky to score 725 runs, and the pitching staff will probably fall back to about 725 runs. As such, we’re talking about a .500 season, which will likely be well behind the Sox.