2008: 72-90 (4th NL East, 20 games back)
This was my worst pick last year – picking them to win the division, only to watch the pitching staff get obliterated by injuries, and a couple of players taking steps back in production. That being said, looking at the 2008 Braves, it’s really confusing to see a team that should have been better finish with a record totally unbefitting its reputation, manager, and its statistics.
Looking Back on 2008
Many people had the Braves to finish at or near the top of the division. Bobby Cox’s team was fronted by two great starters in John Smoltz and Tim Hudson. Tom Glavine returned home and Jair Jurrjens looked ready for his first full season in the rotation. There was a decent power core in Chipper Jones, Mark Teixeira, Brian McCann and Jeff Francoeur, some good young hitters in the infield and outfield – this was a very good team. On paper.
And then the pitching staff was gone. Smoltz made five starts and left without a functioning elbow. Tim Hudson made it into August before his elbow went. Tom Glavine never missed a turn for twenty years – he made just 13 starts. Mike Hampton’s comeback stalled in spring training, he made only 13 starts. Chuck James made seven starts. Lousy starts.
For the first two months, the Braves were more than competitive. Chipper Jones looked like he might hit .400. Other hitters supported the cause. But Smoltz was already gone and Glavine would follow. Five games over .500 approaching Memorial Day, the Braves slumped in June and July and fell out of the race. At that point, the Braves decided to become sellers. Mark Teixeira was given away to the Angels. (For Casey Kotchman? That’s all you could get? Shame!) Mark Kotsay was sent to Boston. When management gave up on the team, the team gave up on the season, going 9 – 20 in August.
And yet, they still should have done better. The team scored nearly as many runs as they allowed, 753 to 778, which means that with a little luck, they might have finished 78 – 84 or so. This was especially problematic on the road, where they were outscored by only four runs, but finished 29 – 52.
Tell me about that offense
The Braves, even without Teixeria now, have a lot of offensive options but will be looking to fill a couple of holes.
The infield is led by third baseman Chipper Jones, who has improved his on base percentage each of the last two years because (a) he’s hitting better than ever, and (b) he’s drawing even more walks than he was in 2006. As such, he’s now creating nearly 11 runs per 27 outs – one of the best rates in baseball. At first base, Mark Teixeira produced runs at a decent clip until he was shipped out. Casey Kotchman arrived and did not – hitting for a low average (.237) with no power (one homer a month). Few teams can win when the first baseman doesn’t produce runs. Kelly Johnson is a decent hitting second baseman; he has some power and a good eye. Last year he hit 39 doubles and 12 homers, which are good numbers from someone who can hit first or second in the lineup. Yunel Escobar didn’t hit .300, but he hit enough, drew a few walks, and finished with double digit homers. Three of the four positions are solidly represented at the plate. Even backup Omar Infante hit pretty well.
Like with the Marlins, the outfield didn’t do its job. Matt Diaz fell from hitting .330 to .244 with no power and only 3 walks against 32 strikeouts in 135 at bats. Mark Kotsay was okay but barely above average and his back is no longer dependable for 120 games anymore. Josh Anderson looked like a better hitter when he arrived in August. And then you have Jeff Francouer, who had a season he’d probably rather forget. He’s gone from 29 homers to 19, and last year finished with 11. His RBI count was down because his batting average fell from .293 to .239. He didn’t strike out more often; he just couldn’t get good contact on the ball. Gregor Blanco, Greg Norton, and Brandon Jones are all decent backups, but aren’t championship quality hitters or defenders.
Brian McCann is the best hitting catcher in baseball – high averages, good power (23 homers and 42 doubles), and good plate discipline, earning some walks and not too many strikeouts.
With the glove, you have a veritable mixed bag of talent, but nobody who really stands out.
McCann’s catching isn’t very good. He makes a few more mistakes (errors, passed balls) than you would like. Only two teams allowed more stolen bases (SD and WASH) and both of those teams play in caverns where it’s hard to bash your way to runs. On the other hand, he’s still mobile and contributes a little bit. With his bat, a few extra stolen bases aren’t going to kill you.
Both Teixeira and Kotchman have great reputations for their glovework, but you wouldn’t have noticed it from their stats where both were actually below average in terms of range (but both were great in not making errors). Chipper Jones had a decent year – a better ratio of double plays to errors, as well as better range than in 2007. However, he’s still slightly below average at third. Of the backups, Martin Prado did the best, and Infante was no better than Jones. Both Escobar and Johnson have slightly above average range, but make more errors than you would like – the signs of young infielders.
Nobody in the outfield was very good. Francouer has slightly below average range but a fantastic arm. Kotsay looked immobile in centerfield (-7.6 range) – in a half season’s worth of innings, he cost the team eleven runs. Gregor Blanco is supposed to be fast, but you wouldn’t know it by his statistics. He cost his team another twelve or thirteen runs. Matt Diaz was their best outfielder and he couldn’t hit.
Despite that, the Braves were about league average overall in terms of turning balls in play into outs, and that was because the infield was pretty good.
Hudson and Smoltz were great, but as you remember, were short term pitchers. Jair Jurrgens, in his first full season, was fantastic finishing with 13 – 10 with a 3.68 ERA in 31 starts. Jorge Campillo was forced into the rotation and was above average in terms of preventing runs in about 160 innings. Mike Hampton and Tom Glavine were slightly below league average but didn’t turn in many innings. In total, the first three slots of the rotation (when you combine them all) were actually pretty good. The last two slots, though, were really bad. Chuck James had an ERA over nine in his seven starts. Charlie Morton was forced into fifteen starts and had an ERA over six. Jo Jo Reyes got 22 starts that the Braves wish didn’t happen. Still – all told, the starters were about eighteen runs better than the average rotation, which was a positive.
The problem was the lack of a consistent bullpen. A couple of options were okay – Jeff Bennett had a solid season. But for every good option, there was at least one pitcher who negated that benefit. Manny Acosta had a decent ERA despite having a lousy strikeout to walk ratio. Blaine Boyer was the opposite – a few too many homers allowed, but good numbers otherwise. Mike Gonzalez came back in the second half to record 14 saves, but had a high ERA. Will Ohman and Buddy Carlisle had okay seasons, but Royce Ring pitched only 22 innings in 42 appearances and had an ERA of 8.46. Like the rotation, there were more positives than negatives, though.
The 2009 Braves will see a lot of changes. Gone are both Hudson and Smoltz. Smoltz signed as a free agent with the Red Sox, who gave him a better guaranteed contract, while Hudson only recently started throwing and is hoping to pitch after the all-star break. In their places will be Derek Lowe and Javier Vasquez. Kenshin Kawakami comes over from Japan and will likely be in the rotation behind Jurrgens, who is the number three starter. That leaves the fifth spot to Campillo, or possibly to rookie Tommy Hanson.
Lowe has been a dependable starter for a long time; in terms of what he offers the Braves he will essentially replace Hudson. Vasquez has been logging innings, but he’s mildly above average because he is a fly ball pitcher. In Atlanta, he might fare a bit better – but he’s still a step down from a full season of Smoltz (not that the Braves got a full season from him). Kawakami is going to be an improvement over Reyes even if he’s league average, and I am reasonably confident Jurrjens will not suffer a sophomore letdown unless his control gets the best of him.
The bullpen didn’t change over the offseason, with the hopes of a full season of Gonzalez and improvement from some younger relievers in the seventh and eighth innings. If the Braves get more innings out of their starters than last year, that will be worth ten runs just not having to dip into long relief as often. The upgrade to the staff is likely worth about twenty or twenty five runs.
Offensively, I’m concerned about the team’s ability to score more runs than last season. Jones turns 37 this April and while he’s been amazing over the last three years, he hasn’t been healthy. Casey Kotchman for a full season will be twenty runs worse (or more) than having a full season of Mark Teixeira. So, the infield may contribute 30 or 40 runs less than last year. Garrett Anderson has been brought in to play left field – he will be an upgrade over what Matt Diaz and Gregor Blanco provided, but he’s also long in the tooth and may need 40 days off over the course of the season. And, he’s not an improvement defensively, either. A full season of Josh Anderson or Blanco in center isn’t going to be that much better than what the Braves got out of Kotsay and others in 2008. So, the key to the outfield will be a comeback season by Francoeur. If he comes back to the levels of the previous two years – 100 runs created instead of 60 – and Anderson stays healthy and hits the way he has in the past, this gets the Braves to about the same level as last season. I like McCann to keep producing for three or four more years.
The optimist says that the team scores about 750 runs and allows about 750 runs – that’s a .500 season. A pragmatist might wonder about what having most of the staff pitching in the World Baseball Classic means to their rotation in September, and worries that the outfield will remain mildly disappointing, and even weaker defensively. If you are Javier Vasquez and you see an outfield that doesn’t run down fly balls, you might be one frustrated pitcher. For that reason, I don’t agree with the optimistic view, and peg the Braves to finish about 78 – 84.
Down on the Farm…
The Braves AAA club in Gwinnett, GA got most of the prospects up to the big leagues. Josh Anderson hit .314 and stole 42 bases. He’s not a free swinger, but doesn’t bring a big OBA to the big leagues, so if he makes it as the starting centerfielder, he probably bats seventh or eighth in this lineup. Charlie Morton pitched well before being called up – in 79 innings, he fanned 72 against only 27 walks and didn’t give up a homer. I think he’ll be okay as a long reliever while he figures things out at the big league level. Most of the rest of the AAA roster, you saw at the major league level much of the last few years.
At AA Mississippi, what impresses you most are the pitchers. Tulsa native Tommy Hanson went 8-4, 3.03 with 114 strikeouts in just 98 innings. Some compare his slider to Smoltz. Todd Redmond went 13 – 5, 3.52 with good control. He has a chance to make the big league roster by the end of 2009 with a good season in AAA next year. Closer Luis Valdez stepped up with 28 saves and a lot of strikeouts. His control may be his only weakness.
Jason Heyward was the star of the A Rome Braves, flashing some power, running the bases, and looking like Francoeur’s replacement by 2011. He’s just 19. Fredrick Freeman also hit well, showing some power while playing first base there – he’s a month younger than Heyward. So, if Kotchman is a dud this year, look for Freeman to be a contender for the job in 2010 – especially if Freeman continues to mature in AA. Edgar Osuna started and relieved in Rome – he looks like he has tools to compete at higher levels. Look for catcher Tyler Flowers to make it to the big leagues one day. His batting stats look like a young Mickey Tettleton at A Myrtle Beach.