Last Five Seasons:
2009: 78 – 84 (4th NL Central)
2008: 74 – 88
2007: 72 – 90
2006: 80 – 82
2005: 73 – 89
The Reds haven’t had a winning season since going 85 – 77 in 2000. It’s time to fix this problem, don’t you think?
Runs Scored: 673 (10th in the NL)
Runs Allowed: 723 (8th in the NL)
Most observers were mixed, but one could see hope on the horizon in guys like Joey Votto, Jay Bruce, and what looked like four potentially good starters. I’m sure the Reds fans thought they should have finished better than .500.
The Reds actually got off to a pretty good start. At one point, Cincinnati was 20 – 14 with Johnny Cueto at 4 – 1, Bronson Arroyo at 5 – 2 and Edinson Volquez at 4 – 2. And then the bad things started to happen. Joey Votto got hurt – and his confidence was suddenly shaken, requiring extra time to come to grips with being out of the lineup and being without his father who had passed away. Volquez went down with an arm injury, taking their ace out of the rotation. After two months looking like a contender, the Reds fell off in June and then fell APART in July.
Cincinnati was 40 – 39 on the Fourth of July. And then the roof caved in falling all the way to 45 – 61 after a loss to Chicago on August 3. The team couldn’t hit – as a group, they batted .240 or less in June, July and August. In July, Red pitchers had an ERA of 5.58 and while August was better, it was their second worst complete month.
To their credit, the Reds unloaded a few problems (Edwin Encarnacion was traded to Toronto for Scott Rolen, Alex Gonzalez was sent to Boston and Paul Janish played shortstop), and got Willy Taveras and his lousy bat out of the leadoff spot. Homer Bailey finally started pitching like a winner. Justin Lehr replaced Micah Owings in the rotation and won five of eight decisions. The rest of the way, the Reds went 33 – 23, which was better than even St. Louis down the stretch.
Having looked at the numbers, adjusting for the defense and the park, I noticed this odd fact. Every pitcher who made a start allowed more runs per nine than the average NL pitcher – a combined 77 runs worse than average. Bronson Arroyo was the closest to average at -0.95, and having pitched the most innings, he’s the ace. Johnny Cueto had his second straight season of running out of gas – he needs to step up big time in 2010. Aaron Harang should be better than this (6 – 14, 4.21)), and yet he’s constantly moving backwards. Micah Owings is the best hitting pitcher ever, probably, but he would have fit in with the Brewers rotation as badly as he pitched. Homer Bailey was on the way to positives, but he didn’t quite make it before the season ended. Even Edinson Volquez didn’t fare exceedingly well in his nine starts.
So, that the Reds went out of the box and signed Aroldis Chapman – who may wind up the fifth starter (crazy, I know it) – was a HUGE step forward. The 20 year old with a 102 mile an hour fastball might start the year in AA, but in a year or two, he could be a serious ace.
If the Reds want to win, their starters have to step up. Arroyo has to hold steady, Harang has to find his mojo, Cueto has to become a REAL #2 starter, and Bailey has to make 25 good starts and not 10. The guy who might make this interesting, but isn’t guaranteed a roster spot is Matt Maloney, who had seven tolerable starts but gave up nine homers. Everything else looks good (28Ks against 8 walks, for example).
The bullpen was pretty good, though. Francisco Cordero was great, Nick Massett was solid, and even Arthur Rhodes – who pitched in Baltimore when Mike Flanagan was still pitching – was really good. If Maloney isn’t going to start, he’s a good long relief option. After that, you have a few “ifs” in Danny Herrera, Carlos Fisher, and Jared Burton. These are guys who aren’t bad and would help more IF they could also step forward.
I like Harang to come back some, Cueto and Bailey to improve some more, and Micah Owings to play right field before too long. I see at least a 25 run net gain. A streak of confidence might make it 50. That’s optimistic, though.
It’s the same group as last year – Ramon Hernandez and Ryan Hanigan. Combined, they provided slightly better than league average catching, and slightly below average hitting. The hope, I guess, is that Hernandez stays healthy, but he’s turning 34 in May, so I wouldn’t bet the farm on it.
Joey Votto is the real deal – like Ryan Braun, Votto is a threat to win a triple crown. It would be nice if the Reds wouldn’t do goofy things like force Ramon Hernandez to first base, but when Votto went down, Dusty Baker decided that Hernandez was Victor Martinez. He’s not. (He’s actually a better fielder, but not a hitter.)
Brandon Phillips remains a great second baseman; durable, a defender, and one of the most productive players in the game.
After a year of letting Alex Gonzalez try to regain his youth, the Reds are going with veteran Orlando Cabrera. This HAS to go better, wouldn’t you think? Paul Janish played spectacularly with the glove, but hits like Mark Belanger, too.
Arriving in a trade, Scott Rolen takes over at third base and if he can fight father time will be a step up over Edwin Encarnacion.
The bench now includes Aaron Miles and Paul Janish, capable gloves even if the bats aren’t really strong. Drew Sutton is also around, but likely will wind up at AAA. And, the ancient Miguel Cairo got a Non-Roster Invite – he could sneak in there.
All told, I like this group to be 30 – 40 runs more productive offensively, and perhaps five runs better defensively. Only Rolen’s health makes me nervous – but at .255 and some power, he’s an improvement. And, Cabrera could get old this year – but he’ll be better than Gonzalez.
This is a young group and I think will be better next year because Willy Taveras is gone. Chris Dickerson isn’t a huge power threat, but he was an above average hitter at 5.4 runs per 27 outs. Give him 500 at bats, and that’s a step up. Jonny Gomes will get at bats (and not catch flies) after hitting 20 homers last season. And I don’t believe that Jay Bruce will hit .223 again (but he might hit 30 homers). Add to that Drew Stubbs, who hit .267 with some power after taking over for Taveras in center. I’m not convinced he’s better than Chris Dickerson (in part because that power isn’t to be expected and he doesn’t have enough patience), but BOTH guys would be better than Taveras.
Arriving from Seattle is Wladimir Balentien, who played well after arriving in late July- but had been disappointing as a Mariner. I like him as a fourth or fifth outfielder. Can Micah Owings shag flies? Put him in left field and let the man hit. Put him at first base when Joey Votto needs a day off and let him hit. Sheesh.
I see perhaps 50 more runs of offense in 2010 from the outfield, with the defense holding steady – and improving if Gomes is a pinch hitter and not a regular outfielder.
The best players in AAA already started getting playing time – Stubbs, Maloney, Lehr, Bailey. Aroldis Chapman may not see any minor league time, and we already mentioned him. So, if you are looking for prospects, we have to look to the lower levels.
Travis Wood is close. At AA Carolina, he went 9 – 3 with a 1.21 ERA (!), in part because he allowed just two homers and had a 3:1 K/W ratio. He earned a shot at AAA where he had eight decent starts. His minor league career has been a bit uneven, so look for Wood to start the year in AAA, but get the first shot at the majors if someone falters. Chris Heisey had an amazing half season at AA, hitting .347 with 13 homers, walking as often as he struck out, and earning a trip to AAA with Wood. He didn’t quite keep up the same pace, but his four years in the minors have shown Heisey to be a hitter. He’ll get another shot at AAA because the Reds have outfield options right now.
Another AA prospect is first baseman Yonder Alonso, the 2008 first round pick out of Miami, who smoked his way through rookie, A, and into AA last year. He’s got some pop, patience, and a .300 average in the minors. Alonso’s spot would seem to be blocked in the majors, though – so the question will be can he move to the outfield, or will he be moved for a pitcher. I think he looks like a young Eddie Murray… Todd Frazier, a 2007 top pick (1A), has hit well, with patience and power, but might not have the range at short and is blocked at second. Frazier MIGHT get a shot, though, if someone gets injured.
Recent early picks aren’t making the same progress. Catcher Devin Mesoraco (2007 – #1) hasn’t hit much in the minors. Kyle Lotzkar walks a lot of batters (24 in 37.2 innings at A Dayton) but, more importantly, has to recover from a broken bone in his elbow that caused him to miss the 2009 season.
I like the Reds to make a splash in 2010. I think the offense might be 80 runs better than last year, with improvement in the outfield and at two infield positions. The defense may be a little better – and there is room for improvement on the staff. I see Cincinnati scoring 750 runs and allowing perhaps 680 – and it could be less. I have them at 89 wins, which isn’t out of the range of possibility. If SOMEBODY can pitch like an ace, look out.
If asked to name a sleeper to make the World Series, it’s the Cincinnati Reds.