New York Yankees
2008: 89-73 (3rd AL East, 8 games back)
The General Motors of baseball – throwing good money into superficial things and veterans only to wind up with nothing because they never really invest in the core of the team, just dressing up what they have and making another run.
Well, this year, by golly, we’re going to spend top dollar on the best players available and fix things! The Yankees spent a half billion on two pitchers and a first baseman (and Nick Swisher). That they bought CC Sabathia was not a surprise. That they risked a lot of money on A.J. Burnett was not totally out of character. However, to have given the rest of the bank to Mark Teixeira seemed like one big check too many – on a team loaded with big checks. Let’s see if they spent it on the right things.
Did you know? Something like 20 of the 86 players mentioned in the Mitchell Report played for Joe Torre? Ah, but that’s just beating a dead horse.
Looking Back on 2008
The Yankees got off to a slow start, winning 14 of 29 in April, but seemed to play better through the rest of the spring and summer. Most months were about 15 – 12 – not great months – which left the team behind the Red Sox and Rays for most of the summer. The pitching fell apart in August, leading to another losing month – but not a 10 – 20 month, just a 13 – 15 month – before actually playing really well down the stretch in September. The problem was that by then, they were too far out of the race.
Part of the problem was injuries. Deteriorating knees (and operations on both of them in the last two seasons) cut into Hideki Matsui’s playing time and offensive contribution. Chien-Ming Wang tore a tendon in his foot in June and was shut down for the rest of the year. Catcher Jorge Posada’s shoulder required surgery. For a while, he tried to play through it – but he couldn’t throw and eventually couldn’t hit. As it was, his batting was well off his amazing 2007 season.
Part of it was that some of the younger guys didn’t produce. Robinson Cano seemed lethargic at the beginning of the season and hit so poorly in April that nobody noticed he hit about .280 or better the rest of the way. Ian Kennedy was given a shot at the starting rotation and left after nine starts with an ERA over 8.00. Phil Hughes took over, pitched a little better – which still wasn’t good enough – and then left with a broken rib. Melky Cabrera had such a poor stretch, he lost his job in centerfield, coming back only when it was obvious that Matsui couldn’t play the field.
The rest is that the best players weren’t at top form. Alex Rodriguez was good, but off from his 2007 MVP numbers. Derek Jeter was rather ordinary, with fewer doubles and homers cutting into his overall production. The Yankees added Xavier Nady, who didn’t exactly set the world on fire when he arrived, and Ivan Rodriguez, who looked old at the plate. Johnny Damon and Bobby Abreu played well – but there were a lot of holes at the bottom of the lineup for too much of the season.
Tell me about that offense
It’s rough when your “off season” is 35 homers, 103 RBI, batting .302 with 18 stolen bases in 21 attempts, but that’s what life is like for A-Rod. Now, Alex Rodriguez will be dealing with a different kind of “off season” – as in his admission for using steroids, and now choosing to undergo surgery on a hip that began troubling him last fall. Derek Jeter has superficially good numbers in a high batting average, but didn’t do much else last year. He is much like Michael Young for Texas. Playing nearly every day and batting at the top of the lineup, he gets a lot of at bats so the numbers look superficially better. However, Jeter generated just 5.4 runs for every 27 outs – above average but not WAY above average. As mentioned, Cano was awful in April – so much so that he finished as a below average producer. He hardly ever walks, so unless he hits .320, he’s not much of a force. Last year, he walked just 26 times, so made a lot of outs. Jason Giambi had a decent year – don’t mind the low batting average (.246), he hit 32 homers and still gets on base a lot.
In the outfield, Johnny Damon was very productive. He hits for a little power now, still is an effective baserunner, and has become more selective at the plate. Bobby Abreu, even now, remains a very productive hitter, with decent power, some speed, and a good eye. At some point, we may have to ask ourselves if Bobby Abreu is a Hall of Famer. After that, however, you have a few more weak links. Matsui is still productive, though his power is waning and his speed is gone. Xavier Nady was okay – hit a few homers in Yankee Stadium, but otherwise had bland numbers. Step down again to Melky Cabrera, who didn’t quite make it to .250, had little power, and doesn’t run well enough to make up for not being on base.
Behind the plate, Posada lost nearly 100 points in his batting average with his shoulder bothering him. This forced the Yankees to play Jose Molina, who hit .216 with little power. When that didn’t work, New York imported Ivan Rodriguez, who hit like Molina and didn’t throw very well. Chad Moeller didn’t impress people with his bat either.
Unlike Yankee teams in the past, you had at least three holes in the lineup (second base, centerfield, and catcher), and with two other off seasons, and little help at DH, the offense was rather ordinary. The Yankees finished seventh in runs scored in the American League.
Not very good.
Let’s start with the admission that it’s very likely that Derek Jeter and Alex Rodriguez are negatively affected by the fact that opponents will let more left handed hitters play in Yankee Stadium than most other parks. STILL, that infield is rather porous. Jeter’s range rating the last three years has been -9.4, -12.3, -9.1. A-Rod? -8.5, -6.1, -5.6. At least he’s gotten better – and he cut down on his errors last year. If the disparity were true, then Cano should be way above average, right? He’s good, but not great. 4.2, 6.5, 5.4. The NET of Jeter and Cano remains below zero – meaning that the infield is letting a lot of balls through to the outfield. Giambi, who battles as best he can, is no Albert Pujols with the glove.
The end result is that if you had a ground ball pitcher, like Wang, he’s actually hurt by not having anybody behind him who can really scoop up grounders. Wang has been successful not because of his defense, but rather because usually the team scores a lot of runs for him.
In the outfield, Cabrera wasn’t good enough, and Damon can’t cover center anymore. Damon is still pretty good in left – but if Matsui is his backup, that’s a problem because Matsui can’t run at all. Abreu in right is no longer a mobile outfielder. Most days, the Yankees were playing five guys in the field who were defensive liabilities – and then you had Posada trying to catch.
Molina was actually very good against the run, allowing just 56% of the baserunners to make it – well above the league average and the best rate in the league. Pudge did better in Detroit, but is finally showing signs of getting long in the tooth behind the plate.
Mike Mussina was great – nearly 30 runs better than the average pitcher despite having no defense behind him. Getting 20 wins for the first (and only) time in his career was a wonderful way to leave the game – and the Yankees will miss him. After that, the only other pitcher to make 30 starts was Andy Pettitte, and he was okay – about seven runs better than the average pitcher. By the way – look at the hits per nine data for these two and you’ll see that the defense isn’t that strong behind them.
After that, you have Wang, who was good for two months, and Joba Chamberlain, who looked great in his 100 innings. This year, look for Chamberlain to get 30 starts and 180 innings – if so, he could be amazing, or he could get hurt. The rest of the staff was pretty weak. Darrell Rasner was given 20 below average starts. We talked about Hughes and Kennedy having poor runs. Sidney Ponson was ordinary in 15 starts, and Carl Pavano was trying to remember how to pitch in his seven starts. So, you had basically 2.5 good pitchers in the rotation – and for this division, that’s not enough.
The bullpen, though, was solid. Mariano Rivera was the best reliever in baseball last year – 27 runs better than the average pitcher in just 70 innings. Brian Bruney, Kyle Farnsworth, Edwar Ramirez, and Jose Veres were excellent in support roles. Most people just didn’t notice because the Yankee gloves didn’t help these guys out. Sure – there were a few duds, but nobody in the pen was really that bad, and none were as bad as an Ian Kennedy.
So, let’s summarize. The problems to address were:
A) Find some starting pitching, especially since their best pitcher retired.
B) Get a better gloves in the outfield and probably at first base.
C) Get more offense out of centerfield, catching spots and hope for some veterans to bounce back some. Also, don’t lose too much offense when Giambi and Abreu leave the team.
I think they did it.
Let’s look at the rotation, as it now features CC Sabathia, A.J. Burnett, Pettitte, Wang, and Chamberlain. To be honest – that’s a force compared with what the Yankees had last year. This could easily be 60 runs better than in 2008. The bullpen needs Rivera to be healthy, but I think the rest of the bullpen will be okay. Rivera won’t be as good as last year – even if he’s healthy and good – so let’s take 15 runs back from the starters. The good news is that the bullpen may need to be used less than before.
Offensively, Nady is not Abreu. Cabrera is fighting with Brett Gardner for the centerfield slot – and frankly, I’d let the burner Gardner play. At least you’d have to improvements in the outfield defensively. The pitchers would appreciate having Gardner in center, for sure. The defensive improvement would be another 20 runs.
With A-Rod gone for a couple of months, having to play Cody Ransom or somebody else for two months (or, if worse comes to worse) longer means losing 60 runs of offense. Granted Teixeira will be a nice addition, but is he that much better than Giambi? Hopefully, he’ll make the defense look a little better. If Jeter and Damon hold steady, and Cano has a better season – I’d still look for the Yankees to score 50 fewer runs than in 2008.
If the Yankees finish with 740 runs scored and 645 runs allowed, they might win about 92 games. That puts them in line with the Rays, who also look to win that many games. My take on it is that the Rays won’t get to 92, which puts the Yankees in line for the wild card slot. And, if they make the playoffs, they would have the front line pitching to compete all the way to the World Series. I don’t think they are better than Boston, but they could win a short series.
Down on the Farm…
You may not have heard of Cody Ransom, but with A-Rod out, you will. Ransom led Scranton/ Wilkes-Barre (AAA) with 22 homers. However, he hit only .255 and struck out enough to think he won’t be much better than, say, a rough Jim Presley… And, he’s not a prospect – he’s 33. The best hitter, though, was probably Brett Gardner. Gardner is a burner with no power, but he walks and bunts and could help the pitching staff with his defense. The pitching staff is filled with people you’ve probably heard of before – Kei Igawa, Kennedy, Hughes, and the like.
AA Trenton doesn’t have much to brag about, but Phil Coke is a pitcher you might see once in a while. Coke has slowly moved through the minors, but at AA Trenton he was 9 – 4 with good K/W numbers. Coke got a shot at AAA and even saw time with the Yankees and pitched very well in 14 innings. At best, he’s a long shot to pitch long relief and may start the season in AAA.
Catcher Jesus Montero batted .326 with power, leading the Charleston River Dogs (A+) in RBI. He’s just 19, and figures to be a replacement for Posada by 2011. I’d pick him as the top prospect on the team (Baseball America says he’s #6 in the system). Baseball America says Brooklyn’s Dellin Betances is a better prospect – he’s a 20 year old pitcher who had big strikeout numbers for Charleston, but he looks like he needs to gain more control of the strike zone. Still – look for the Yankees to trade him in a future July deal. Betances is 6’ 8” and about 250 pounds, so he must be intimidating. Zachary McAllister is working his way up quickly, winning 14 with a 2.09 ERA at two levels, finishing at Tampa (A+) last year.