Evan Longoria – TB (125.6 Runs Created, 31.1 Runs Saved = 156.7 Total Runs Productivity)
Not sure if people thought he was as good as Robinson Cano last year (including me), but once you add up the numbers, he was the most valuable player in the AL last year. A remarkable ballplayer.
Adrian Beltre – BOS (116.5 Runs Created, 19.0 Runs Saved = 135.5 Total Runs Productivity)
Now THAT’s a contract year season, huh? He has this kind of ability, and if he did this every year he’d be headed to the Hall of Fame. Instead, he’s heading to Texas. Kevin Youkilis, certainly capable of this kind of productivity when healthy, will get the nod in 2011.
Jose Lopez – SEA (60.7 Runs Created, 36.9 Runs Saved = 97.6 Total Runs Productivity)
Handled the move from second to third very nicely, playing with surprisingly good range and avoiding mistakes often made by first timers to the hot corner. Doesn’t have much power left, and I don’t think he can repeat this performance. Now, he’s in Colorado, which means that Chone Figgins will return to third base.
Miguel Tejada – BAL (75.8 Runs Created, 21.2 Runs Saved = 97.0 Total Runs Productivity)
Wasn’t really cutting it offensively, but did a great job as a third baseman. Was sent to San Diego for the stretch drive where he returned to the shortstop position and gave him a little bit of life. He can still play well enough to help somebody. Josh Bell didn’t cut it as his back up, and former Snake basher, Mark Reynolds, will get the job in 2010.
Michael Young – TEX (94.0 Runs Created, -10.3 Runs Saved = 83.7 Total Runs Productivity)
Plays every day, hits a bit, and got better defensively in his second year at the position. Yes – Beltre is a step up from Young, but you don’t want guys like Young to go away. Could get 150 games backing up both Kinsler and Beltre and playing DH from time to time.
Alex Rodriguez – NYY (85.0 Runs Created, -2.4 = 82.6 Total Runs Productivity)
Superficially, he hit the 30/100 milestones. Defensively, he’s gotten better the longer he has played third base, but his bat is slipping (age, lack of chemical help) and his health is no longer dependable for 150 games.
Mark Reynolds, your new Oriole 3B, would rank here at 79.7 Total Runs Productivity…
Brandon Inge – DET (67.6 Runs Created, 11.0 Runs Saved = 78.6 Total Runs Productivity)
Can still play the position well, but is – at best – a league average hitter.
At 71.8 Total Runs Productivity, former Indian Jhonny Peralta would rank here. I just can’t tell if he’s moving back to third base soon.
Kevin Kouzmanoff – OAK (64.0 Runs Created, -1.5 Runs Saved = 62.5 Total Runs Productivity)
A dependable player, but not one you can build a team around.
Alberto Callaspo – KC/LAA (66.4 Runs Created, -7.5 Runs Saved = 58.9 Total Runs Productivity)
Has had better years, but I’m not sure he’s a long term solution for the Angels, who gave up on their other options in 2010. The Royals gave the job to Wilson Betemit, but he’ll be a bench option before too long. For the Angels, it’s hard to see who might be the third baseman of the future – so Callaspo better put his career back in gear.
Danny Valencia – MIN (48.8 Runs Created, -1.2 Runs Saved = 47.6 Total Runs Productivity)
The Boca Raton native and Hurricane grad got the call in 2010 and did well enough, helping produce a few runs and battling the position to a draw. He might show a little more power as he ages, but isn’t going to be a bomber. I’d call him the new Joe Randa. Nick Punto and Brendan Harris are both pretty good third baseman (Punto with the glove and Harris, occasionally, with the bat), but Punto will start 2011 on the DL following surgery to repair a sports hernia and Harris is in Baltimore where he may or may not play 100 games.
Edwin Encarnacion – TOR (48.1 Runs Created, -4.5 Runs Saved = 43.6 Total Runs Productivity)
Not very consistent, but he really can be a good player. Bautista, if he played here every day and hit like he did last year would move WAY up the list, and he handled the position defensively better than Edwin did.
Jayson Nix – CLE (35.0 Runs Created, 1.8 Runs Saved = 36.8 Total Runs Productivity)
Not even sure he’ll start, since MLB.com lists Jason Donald as the prospective starting third baseman (and he didn’t log an inning at third in 2010) – which makes it hard to figure who to draft in a full AL Only fantasy league. Neither Donald, Nix, or Andy Marte cut it last year after Peralta left.
Wilson Betemit – 53.4 Runs Created, -21.4 Run Saved = 32.0 Total Runs Productivity)
Hit better than he would have expected (13 – 43 – .297 in 84 games), and fielded much worse than expected. He’s really somewhere in between there and worth having on the team. However, the Michael Moustakas era will begin in 2011 – and the question is how long will the Royals wait for that to get started? Opening Day? June – to push back arbitration eligibility a year? Moustakas hit 36 homers in AA and AA last year and is just 22.
Mark Teahen – CHI (28.0 Runs Created, -9.9 Runs Saved = 18.1 Total Runs Productivity)
Reason #2 why the White Sox didn’t win the AL Central. Teahen was brought here from Kansas City to at least give league average production, and he couldn’t stay healthy, he couldn’t hit enough, and his glove wasn’t working either at three positions. May get another chance, but I’m not sure I’d want to be the guy to give it to him. Brett Morel may be the man of the future, having earned a shot after three solid years of growth in the minors. Morel looks like he has a little power and a little speed – and at 24 just after Opening Day, he has room for growth.
Omar Vizquel – CHI (38.8 Runs Created, -27.0 Runs Saved = 11.8 Total Runs Productivity)
Reason #1 why the White Sox didn’t win the AL Central. Vizquel was pressed into playing more than 500 innings here, after never being a third baseman before. He’s not the run producer most teams expect at this position, and he looked very much old and out of place.
Brandon Wood – LAA (8.9 Runs Created, -11.4 Runs Saved = -2.5 Total Runs Productivity)
Can we declare his days as a prospect over now?