2008: 68-93 (5th AL East, 28.5 games back)
Runs Scored: 782
Runs Allowed: 869
With the trade of Miguel Tejada and Erik Bedard to Houston and Seattle respectively for prospects, 2008 represented the first year of a rebuilding plan in the American League’s toughest division. But these Orioles weren’t half bad. Sure, they were 22 – 50 inside their division, but actually above .500 against everyone else (46 – 43). The reason? The Orioles had a decent offense and a handful of young pitchers finding their way. It’s a good time to be a Baltimore fan – just don’t expect to make the playoffs until a rotation anchor or two can be found.
Looking Back on 2008
With 782 runs scored, the Orioles finished in the middle of the league in terms of scoring – just a few runs behind the Yankees. What they lacked was pitching and defense – having allowed 869 runs, which was next to last in the American League.
Baltimore got off to a great start – winning sixteen in April and fighting for the division lead for the first month. Things slowed in May thanks to a streak against their own division where they lost ten of thirteen, but a solid June followed. Even though the leaders in the division were starting to pull away, the Orioles were still five games over .500 as late as June 20th. Heck, if Toronto had a 39 – 34 record at this point in the season, the way they finished, the Blue Jays might have won a playoff spot.
Instead, the Orioles got cold after the all-star break. Ending a five-game losing streak had them at .500 for the last time on July 11th, and from that point on, Baltimore was a non-factor, losing a few games each month to .500 until September, when playing rookies killed the overall record. The Orioles went 5 – 20 to close the season, ruining what had been, until then, a reasonably successful summer in Camden Yards.
Tell me about that offense
Behind the plate, the new Cincinnati Red, Ramon Hernandez, held his own. He provided a little power, and a .250+ batting average, but not much else. Hernandez has actually slipped some from his performance in 2006, which didn’t help, but his backup, Guillermo Quiroz, couldn’t hit .200 in 134 at bats.
The infield was reasonably strong at two spots. Third baseman Melvin Mora had a decent enough season, driving in 104 runs and batting .285. Second sacker Brian Roberts is a great leadoff hitter, just missing .300, hitting 51 doubles, adding some triples and homers, a lot of walks, and 40 stolen bases in 50 chances. Kevin Millar struggled to hit .234, but even that had a few homers and some walks. For the position, that’s not good enough and he’s likely to move to a bench role with another team in 2009. Where the Orioles really struggled was finding a consistent option at short. Of the guys playing at least 200 innings (and nobody played more than 400 innings there), the best hitting option was former White Sox prospect Alex Cintron, who hit .286 but with little power or other helpers. The rest averaged about .200 as a group, including Brandon Fahey, Freddie Bynum, and Juan Castro.
The outfield featured rookie Adam Jones, who hit .270, but showed room for power potential, a little speed, but not much else at this stage. As such, he’s mildly below average as a hitter, but if he could step forward one or two notches, he could help. Luke Scott came over from Houston and hit well enough, with 23 homers and showing some plate discipline. However, his occasional platoon partner, Jay Payton, struggled at the plate – so the net result wasn’t exactly positive. Rightfielder Nick Markakis continued to show growth as a future star, hitting for power (20 – 87 – .306) and getting on base.
If Markakis wasn’t the best hitter on the team, it was Aubrey Huff, who had a career season (32 – 108 – .304.) Both scored about 7.5 runs per 27 outs, and anchored the offense. Only Oscar Salazar hit well off the bench, and he didn’t have 100 plate appearances.
Baltimore pitchers worked with a defense that was not quite league average… The league turned converted 68.6% batted balls in play into outs. Baltimore finished at .68.5%.
Around the horn, Mora and Millar was just a touch above average, while Brian Roberts was just a touch below league average. Most of the shortstops had decent defensive stats except Bynum, so while the offense at short was lacking, the defense was not. However, the team was rather weak in terms of turning double plays in part because there were a lot of flyball pitchers and Roberts was working with a different partner most of the season.
Markakis and Scott were a shade off of league average, while Adam Jones was slightly worse than that. When Jay Payton played, he couldn’t hit but the ball found his glove. Luis Montanez, however, played three outfield positions and never seemed to be standing where the ball was hit… Between them all, the outfield was actually below average and with a fly ball staff, this was a problem.
Hernandez had an awful year throwing out runners – 99 of the 123 people who tried to steal were successful. Throw in the fact that he was slightly above average in terms of mistakes per game and that the staff’s ERA and winning percentage wasn’t very strong, my system suggests that Hernandez was among the weaker catchers in the AL.
Only two pitchers had really strong seasons for Baltimore. Starter Jeremy Guthrie was about 19 runs better than the average pitcher, going 10 – 12, with good control through a few too many balls left the yard. It was the second solid season for Guthrie, who is far and away the ace of the staff. Middle reliever Jim Johnson didn’t allow a homer all season, which kept his ERA down, and despite having ordinary walk and strikeout data was also valuable for the Orioles.
Unfortunately, too many guys were WAY below average here. Among the rotation starters, Brian Burres (-21 runs), Daniel Cabrera (-14 runs), Radhames Liz (-22 runs), Garrett Olson (-29 runs), and Steve Trachsel (-20 runs in 8 starts) got the Orioles in the hole early all too often. Chris Waters came up and had 11 middling to below average starts with a 5.01 ERA and was an improvement.
The bullpen had Chad Bradford for a while, and George Sherrill had 33 saves, but they weren’t by any means awesome. Sherrill’s ERA was 4.73, so he wasn’t setting the AL on fire as the Orioles’ fireman. Most of the other relievers, including Dennis Sarfate, Lance Cormier, Jamie Walker and others struggled to put up league average numbers. Compare that to the staffs of Boston, New York, or Tampa (much less Toronto), and you can see where the team needs to improve.
Ideally, the Orioles would like to see a little more offense, but more importantly, they have to find ways to keep the other team from scoring runs. To get to .500, you’re talking about cutting more than 100 runs from the runs allowed, which means finding six decent pitchers and improving the outfield defense.
Offensively, the changes start at catcher (Greg Zaun for Ramon Hernandez, with Matt Wieters possibly getting his shot at some point this season), as well as first base (Millar is gone, with Ty Wigginton here). Cesar Izturis arrives from St. Louis to play short – he’s not a championship quality hitter, but will be an improvement over the crew who played here last year. It looks like the Orioles will not be trading Brian Roberts (they shouldn’t), which helps, and if Melvin Mora stays productive, the infield will be solid. Defensively, they are probably 5 to 10 runs better, and offensively they are probably 15 runs better.
The outfield has added Felix Pie and Ryan Freel, but I don’t see how either of them will take Jones, Scott, or Markakis out of the lineup. However, Pie could be the surprise – and as a defensive replacement, he’ll be solid. The outfield of Scott, Jones, and Markakis can still produce runs, but more importantly there are a couple of bench performers who can contribute. Offensively this is probably worth ten runs, and defensively, this could be worth ten runs, too.
Zaun is a better defensive catcher than Hernandez, but he’s been catching since Doug Ault was in Toronto (not really), and his contribution will not last the season. Of the NRIs, Robby Hammock might play, and he can at least hit the ball some. Chad Moeller and Guillermo Quiroz are in camp, but neither will be making a big contribution in the near future. Matt Wieters has a job as soon as he’s ready.
One assumes that Huff should stay productive in his role, but he was so good last year, it wouldn’t surprise me if he’s off by ten runs this season.
There are, oh, 120 pitchers in camp in Ft. Lauderdale hoping to make the Orioles roster in April. Guthrie is still here, and Rich Hill arrives from Chicago trying to put his career back together. Hill would be a step up if he brings his best game. The rest are a bunch of unknowns. Matt Alberts was better as a reliever, but he could start some and be an improvement of ten runs over somebody. Brian Bass comes over from Minnesota where, as a reliever, he wasn’t special. As a starter he was tolerable here in Baltimore. He might get a shot. Troy Patton came over with the Tejada deal, he might be ready for a few starts. George Sherrill needs to up his performance – and someone else needs to help out in the bullpen.
The problem is that they are all unproven rookies or second year guys. Could they be better? Sure – but it’s just not something you can predict with any dependability.
As such, I see the runs scored/runs allowed breakdown to be somewhere around 800/850, which translates to about 76 wins. In this division, that’s a tall order, but there are enough pieces to see a better team in Baltimore. If one or two pitchers step up in the rotation – a Hill and a Sherrill, for example – suddenly these guys are approaching .500 – and that’s pretty impressive. When a few more young arms make it to the majors, this team might be ready to compete for a playoff spot.
Down on the Farm…
AAA Norfolk’s best hitter was Oscar Salazar (13 – 85 – .316), who got a cup of coffee with the big league club and played well. He could have slid into the first base slot, and may well get this job after spending a decade in the minors (he’s 30). He’s just been blocked everywhere he’s been (Oakland, the Mets, Detroit, Kansas City, Anaheim, and Cleveland), and he wasn’t a good enough middle infielder when he was younger. However, with the ability to play the whole infield, he’s a good bench option. Radhames Liz and Jim Miller pitched well enough to earn shots with the parent club last year.
Matt Wieters, the future catcher, hit .365 at AA Bowie in 208 at bats, with 12 homers and 51 RBI. He can’t be far off… Lou Montanez and Nolan Reimhold hit for power; Montanez had the higher batting average, but Reimhold has the better plate discipline. David Hernandez and Chris Tillman led a quartet of Bay Sox pitchers to double-digit victories (the others were Brad Bergeson and Jason Berken, two other potential studs). Both showed killer K/9 rates and will be in line for rotation spots by 2010 if not sometime this summer. Julio Manon dominated as the closer – he’s just not a young prospect. He’s 36 this summer.
Cole McMurray and Pat Egan led the hurlers at Aberdeen (High A), with closer Brandon Cooney (from nearby Florida Atlantic – near me, anyway) showing strong numbers. Other than Wieters, the Frederick Keys also had first baseman Brandon Snyder (15 – 80 – .315) and pitchers Brandon Erbe and Jake Arrieta, who both had strong strikeout numbers if not solid won-loss records.