Last Five Seasons:
2010: 88 – 74
2009: 79 – 83
2008: 89 – 74
2007: 72 – 90
2006: 90 – 72
The White Sox have been competitive for much of the last six or seven years, 2007 notwithstanding.
Runs Scored: 752 (7th in the AL)
Runs Allowed: 704 ( 8th in the AL)
With this combination, the White Sox would be expected to win 86 games or so – right about where they finished.
At the beginning of the season, many expected the White Sox to contend with the Twins for the AL Central crown, and they contended until the last few days of the season.
The Sox actually got off to kind of a slow start, having losing records in April and May. At one point, the Sox were eight games under .500 and threatening to finish in last place at 24 – 33 after a loss to Detroit. However, the Sox got SCORCHING HOT, winning eleven in a row and fifteen of sixteen to sprint back into the race. (Of course, they played the Cubs, Pirates, Nationals, and Braves for that stretch, losing only a 1 – 0 game to Ted Lilly and the Cubs which likely saved Lou Piniella’s job.) Another nine game winning streak got the Sox to 50 – 39, at which point people started to think playoffs.
Once they had to face teams in their division, however, the Sox fell back. Only one more hot streak – a seven game winning streak in the beginning of September – kept them alive. Then, facing the Twins and Tigers, the Sox lost eight in a row (the last two to Oakland), and they were done. The Twins beat the Sox 13 times, the difference between first and second place.
During the season, the Sox acquired two players, trading Daniel Hudson and David Holmberg to Arizona for Edwin Jackson and claiming Manny Ramirez from the Dodgers after he had been waived. Neither player figured heavily in the team’s fortunes down the stretch. Jackson pitched reasonably well in his eleven starts; Manny – not so much, but only batted 69 times.
The Sox have a LOT of quality starting pitching. John Danks was fantastic – 213 innings and saving his team 24 runs over that span. Mark Buehrle did what he always does, throws strikes, eats innings, and wins games. Gavin Floyd was saddled with a losing record but, like Buehrle is an above average pitcher with a record of durability. Jake Peavy was expected to be the ace, but he suffered a significant tear in a muscle behind his throwing shoulder and hopes to be back for much of the 2011 season after having an experimental surgery to repair it. Last year’s #5, Freddy Garcia, was surprisingly effective in 28 starts but won’t be back because Edwin Jackson is about the best fifth starter you can possibly imagine. 37 wins in the last three years, a no-hitter last year, and a power arm. It’s hard to find a better overall rotation outside of Philadelphia anywhere.
Bobby Jenks and his 4.44 ERA is no longer the closer, having moved on to Boston. And, J.J. Putz, the former set up man, is a closer in Arizona. Don’t worry about the Pale Hose, though, because the rest of the bullpen is as good as the rotation. Chris Sale was impressive in 23.1 innings, striking out 32 batters and allowing just 15 hits – and becomes the new closer. His late season dominance allowed Jenks, who was losing his effectiveness, to leave town. Scott Thornton has been a solid reliever for a couple of years now and becomes the lock down set up man. Sergio Santos was effective, Jesse Crain and Will Ohman have been imported to provide middle inning support options, and Tony Pena can do the job as a swing man or long reliever.
The Sox have a decent tandem in A.J. Pierzynski and Ramon Castro. Pierzynski is starting to show signs of age, but is still reasonably effective. Castro is a good enough hitter to warrant more playing time if needed. As a defensive unit, the two were above average in five categories (ERA, Winning Percentage, Caught Stealing, Mistakes per Game, and Fielding Percentage on plays other than strikeouts), and below average only in mobility categories.
Both offensively and defensively, you had two positions working in the Sox favor, and two working the other way. Paul Konerko remains a sturdy bat in the middle of the lineup, but defensively he and his 2010 backup, Mark Kotsay, are well below average. At second base, Gordon Beckham, you had the opposite. Beckham has decent enough defensive skills, but didn’t hold his own with the bat in 2010, unlike what he suggested was possible in 2009. At short, Alexei Ramirez was solid offensively despite a rather low OBP because he hit for power and had a reasonably good batting average. And, defensively, he played at a gold glove level. Then you have the hole at third, where Mark Teahan had an off year and couldn’t stay healthy either – costing the team runs with the glove and bat. The person who played the most at third was the elder statesman, Omar Vizquel, who looked very out of place defensively and hit like Paul Bako with even less power.
Arriving to help the cause is Brent Morel, a third round pick in 2008 out of Cal Poly, who has shown a plus bat and some power. In AA and AAA, he hit 10 – 60 – .322 and earned a 21 game tryout with the Sox in September. If Morel can hold his own at the position and hit .280 with a dozen homers, this would be a significant step up for the Sox over what played there in 2010.
Alex Rios came over from Toronto, played center extremely well, and put a lot of runs on the board – his best season since signing that huge contract a few years ago. Juan Pierre remains the left fielder – though Mighty Casey can’t explain it. For a guy who is supposed to be fast, he’s NOT a plus range fielder, and unless he’s hitting .320, he’s a waste of at bats. In right, Carlos Quentin was so bad defensively that he offset whatever benefits having Rios and Pierre in center and left may have provided. His power is still around, but he misses a lot games (much less pitches). I think the Sox will miss Andruw Jones, who can’t really cover any ground but hit 19 homers in essentially a half season of at bats. Alejando De Aza is the new fourth outfielder, a guy I used to root for in Florida, and is running out of chances to stick. He can play a little.
Last year, there was a rotation of hitters, none who will be anywhere as good as the newly signed free agent, Adam Dunn. Dunn is an offensive force, and gives the team depth at left or first base, too. (He can’t field them, but he can certainly hit enough so that you won’t notice too much.)
Down on the Farm:
Brett Morel we covered… Behind him on the AAA depth chart is 3B-1B candidate Dayan Viciedo, a 22-year-old Cuban kid with serious power and upside and didn’t disappoint when given a shot with the parent club in 2010. If Paul Konerko starts to get old, Viciedo could step in and be a quality first baseman for more than a decade. Pitcher Daniel Hudson looked to be close to ready, but was sent to Arizona for Edwin Jackson at the trade deadline. Hudson looked like he could be as good as Jackson, but Arizona is rebuilding while the White Sox are merely retooling.
At AA Birmingham, first baseman Jimmy Gallagher had a season that looks like something on the back of Mark Grace’s baseball card, but may not have a future here unless it’s as a pinch hitter. The pitcher who stands out, to me anyway, is reliever Deunte Heath, who fanned 84 in 57.2 innings, but may have issues harnessing his control. Anthony Carter also had a decent season in relief.
A guy who seems to have the team’s eye is Gregory Infante, who converted from a starter to a reliever and blew through A+ Winston-Salem and then Birmingham. 69Ks in 60 innings, didn’t allow a single homer (just 12 in 291 minor league innings), and for a really young kid out of Caracas, Venezuela, he may get a shot at closing in AAA. A guy you may read about in 2011 could be Justin Greene, a centerfielder with speed and power who also blew through A+ and landed at AA. Dylan Axelrod had a 1.99 ERA in Winston-Salem, earning a promotion to AA, and things are finally starting to click for him. Working against him is the fact that he’s a late round pick originally drafted by San Diego, and the Sox having a lot of starters at the big league level who aren’t going away anytime soon.
I’m feeling a bit optimistic about the Sox, mostly because Dunn and Morel could quickly address the two biggest weaknesses they have. You have the potential regression of Pierzinski, Konerko, Pierre, Rios, and Quentin, weighed against the potential of gaining 80 or more offensive runs with Morel and Dunn. The pitching staff will be equally solid and could be marginally better – and would be really good if there weren’t two holes on the same side of the field (Konerko, Quentin). Still – a full season of Morel at third should help the overall defense, too. I like getting Jenks out of the closer role, and the Sox pen is still very, very good. I like the White Sox scoring 825 runs and allowing barely 700, which puts the sox at 95 wins. I also think the Sox could win the World Series, another shot across the bow at Cub fans who continue to wait for a miracle that won’t arrive until they figure out how to manage resources.
Working against the Sox is the idea that Jake Peavy’s shoulder may explode at any moment, and Ozzie Guillen imploding after another irrational outburst at his general manager, who has assembled quite the roster. Ozzie – sit back and enjoy the ride to the playoffs.